Congress shouldn’t rig college sports for the rich and powerful

Congress shouldn’t rig college sports for the rich and powerful

Most conservatives instinctively understand that government intervention in the marketplace not only has unintended consequences but often hurts those it claims to help. That’s why no Republican should support the Protect College Sports Act.The bill purports to save college sports from the marketplace. But the marketplace is not something they should be “saved” from.The marketplace has long enriched nearly everyone involved in college sports – except college athletes. Why should Congress allow the industry to go back to the days when it was only allowed to enrich schools? For decades, amateurism applied only to athletes. Schools, conferences, television networks, and administrators could collect their millions while insisting that paying players would compromise the purity of college sports. Like Captain Renault in Casablanca, professing to be “shocked, shocked” by gambling while pocketing his winnings, college sports leaders condemned commercialism while cashing their checks. Everyone could profit from the game except the athletes who made it possible.That changed in 2021, when the Supreme Court ruled athletes could finally earn money from endorsements, autograph signings, and other uses of their identities – the same kinds of commercial opportunities that others in college sports had enjoyed for years (e.g., coaches such as Nick Saban and Dion Sanders). Conservatives should recognize that as a victory for economic freedom: individuals gaining the right to profit from their own talents.Under the new rules since 2021, schools must now compete for athlete services because the marketplace now determines their value.In some cases, athletes are making what many would consider untold riches. It’s not rare to see a college football or basketball player make $5 million for their services. But as any free-market advocate would say, the marketplace should determine value.Top athletes are no longer recruited by facilities, faculty, and coaches alone. Recruits now often expect a financial incentive too. For athletes, it is the payday they have worked their whole lives for.College athletes’ ability to negotiate has positively affected them in other ways as well. For example, athletes who transferred schools were punished and forced to sit a year. Today, they can change schools without a sword of Damocles hanging over their head.Is compensating college athletes a crisis so severe that the federal government must step in and rewrite the rules, not in favor of athletes, but of institutions and conferences? I think not.At its core, the Protect College Sports Act grants antitrust exemptions to create new regulations regarding athlete compensation. The bill creates a price cap on NIL deals with athletes, limits their ability to transfer schools, and shields schools from legal challenges. The bill also overrides conflicting state laws in states that established their own rules. This would amount to federal action to dictate the market terms in all states, to the advantage of big conferences and to the disadvantage of athletes’ market power.Conservatives should not defend free enterprise while at the same time asking Washington to protect college sports from competition. If this bill becomes law, schools would still negotiate lucrative television contracts, hire expensive coaches, and sell sponsorships to the highest bidder. Shouldn’t athletes enjoy the same freedom to negotiate based on their market value?IRAN IS TRYING TO KILL OUR LEADERS. HOW WILL IMPEACHING PETE HEGSETH MAKE AMERICA SAFER?Competing for talent may be inconvenient, but that does not justify federal intervention to suppress its price. Athletes have earned the right to be compensated for their services, and the NCAA, which worked tirelessly to ensure athletes were never paid, should not be rewarded with federal protection after decades of denying students that freedom.Competition isn’t chaos. Lawmakers should resist the temptation to move back in the direction of an arrangement that enriched institutions while limiting the opportunities of those who filled the stadiums. House Republicans should reject this bill and reaffirm a principle long held dear by conservatives: Economic freedom belongs to everyone, even those who aren’t big and powerful enough to retain lobbyists like the big college conferences.Hon. Ken Cuccinelli served as the 46th attorney general of Virginia, as well as the acting deputy secretary for Homeland Security under President Donald Trump.

Original Source

Read the full article at Washingtonexaminer →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.