Company behind FAA ‘SMART’ AI system under scrutiny after ground stop mess

Company behind FAA ‘SMART’ AI system under scrutiny after ground stop mess

The unprecedented nationwide ground stop imposed by the Federal Aviation Administration on Friday has triggered public speculation as to whether the agency’s recent implementation of an AI-powered dashboard caused the disruption.The Strategic Management of Airspace, Routes, and Trajectories dashboard is a tool the FAA implemented nationwide this fall, prompting some to speculate that it was the cause of last week’s air fiasco.FAA insiders say SMART is not the problem, and the agency has blamed a different technological problem for the ground stop. However, the tech startup behind the SMART, Air Space Intelligence, has become a public focus amid the fallout. The scrutiny has extended to an in-house political action committee for ASI that donated money to Rep.-elect Michael Alfonso (R-WI), Duffy’s son-in-law, months before the $875 million contract from the FAA was awarded.SMART system comes under public scrutiny On Nov. 10, the FAA expanded SMART to all 22 high-altitude air traffic control centers. The cloud-based platform brings together existing airline schedules, weather, airport capacity, airspace conditions, and other data to recommend route changes that can improve efficiency and speed.Three days later, the FAA took emergency action and imposed a five-hour nationwide ground stop on departures. Between Friday and Monday morning, 18,400 flights were canceled, aviation analytics company Cirium told the Washington Examiner, rendering millions of passengers stranded.On Sunday, the agency reported that 17 of its 22 centers had telecommunications disrupted as a result of a router upgrade, prompting speculation among the public that SMART was to blame.ASI posted a statement on X that said the ground stop “is not based on or a result of the SMART system, any product of ASI or our integration with FAA and ATC.”The FAA’s Telecommunications Infrastructure is a nationwide, secure network that connects all air traffic control facilities, airports, and FAA systems across U.S. airspace. When an FTI line goes down, it means the circuit has failed, potentially leading to the loss of communications between air traffic control facilities and the failure of certain operational equipment.The FAA emphasized again on Sunday that SMART was not involved in the disruption.“Q: Was this caused by SMART system?” an FAA question-and-answer document states. “No. The two systems are not related. SMART is a data aggregator, and it does not feed information into the air traffic control system.”Duffy’s son-in-law received $2,500 from ASI on campaign trail Despite the Trump administration’s insistence that SMART did not cause the disruption, ASI has received significant attention since Friday over the company’s donations to Duffy’s son-in-law, as well as how it obtained a massive contract with the FAA.ASI’s political action committee donated $2,500 to the congressional campaign of Duffy’s son-in-law Alfonso in March, placing him among the top recipients of the PAC’s spending this midterm cycle.In a statement, Alfonso emphasized his independence from special interest groups and rejected any suggestion that his family connections have earned him favor or would influence his decisions in Washington.“I can’t be bought,” Alfonso told the Washington Examiner. “Unlike Nancy Pelosi and many career politicians, I’m going to Washington to fight for Wisconsin, not special interests, and that’s exactly why I support banning stock trading by members of Congress. I’ll weigh every bill on its own merits, including any FAA funding request, and vote based on what’s best for Wisconsin. Family ties don’t earn anyone special treatment, and my father-in-law knows better than anyone that I think for myself.”Alfonso, 26, won the same House seat previously held by his father-in-law to become the youngest member of Congress.Alfonso also received financial support from major transportation companies, including $5,000 from Delta Air Lines PAC, $2,500 from Southwest Airlines PAC, and $2,000 from Lockheed Martin Corporation Employees’ PAC.ASI lands $875 million contract Bidding details show that 12 offers were received for the $875 million SMART contract. Despite being a relatively small growth-stage startup, ASI reportedly beat two larger competitors, Palantir Technologies and Thales, for the award.Federal acquisition records describe the awards process as “full and open competition” after the exclusion of certain vendors for authorized cost-cutting or supply-chain reasons.FAA insisted that the SMART contract was awarded through a competitive selection process overseen by career experts and that ASI was ultimately chosen after outperforming two other finalists.“Each FAA contract goes through a rigorous, competitive process guided by nonpartisan career experts and personnel,” an agency spokesperson told the Washington Examiner. “The FAA awarded the contract to Air Space Intelligence (ASI) following an innovative challenge with three vendors who demonstrated the highest levels of reliability, operational performance, and efficiency.”The SMART contract was issued to ASI on June 23.Exactly three months later, on Sept. 21, the FAA rolled out SMART in a limited capacity.Safety concerns Congressional Democrats contacted the Government Accountability Office and asked the federal office to audit the new system due to concerns about safety and guardrails in October.“The use of artificial intelligence within SMART has rightfully raised serious questions about its reliability and safety benefits, particularly on its potential to interfere with decision-making by experienced air traffic controllers or to hallucinate safety-critical information,” the lawmakers wrote in an October letter.Specifically, House Democrats are concerned that air-traffic controllers had no input in the process and will now be required to understand a system built without taking their perspectives into consideration.Rep. Don Beyer (D-VA) has also questioned why the FAA piloted and debuted SMART at Reagan National Airport in Northern Virginia without independent testing, public notice, or safety guardrails.The FAA and ASI did not respond to requests for comment about any response provided to lawmakers or whether it conducted any safety reviews ahead of the implementation.FAA seeking ownership stake in ASI FAA was reportedly in talks to own a stake in ASI, not just do business with it as a government contractor.As of mid-October, the federal agency was working to acquire an ownership stake in the private company, according to an internal FAA document obtained by Politico.Politico’s reporting was based on the FAA drafting a term sheet for an equity stake in ASI, which serves as a nonbinding document outlining the terms and conditions of an investment deal or proposed business agreement. Term sheets help both parties clarify details of an arrangement before entering a legal contract.FAA LIFTS NATIONWIDE GROUND STOP FOLLOWING HISTORIC HALT ON AIR TRAVELIt is unclear whether any deal was reached or remains in the works. ASI did not respond to the Washington Examiner’s inquiry about the reported dealings and the FAA could not comment without a copy of the term sheet at issue.Politico reported that the term sheet lapses at the end of 2026 and negotiations for what’s known as a stock warrant were underway. A stock warrant would allow the federal government, as the warrant holder in this case, to buy or sell the company’s shares at a set price during a specified time frame. When exercised, warrants can create new shares and thereby dilute existing ownership.ASI announced on Oct. 20, five days after Politico’s piece, that it had raised $325 million at a $3 billion valuation “to power America’s critical infrastructure with AI.” Spark Capital led the financing push, joined by affiliates of Citadel Securities, Meritech Capital, Craft Ventures, Energy Impact Partners, and venture capital firm Andreessen Horowitz.

Original Source

Read the full article at Washingtonexaminer →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.