Communications watchdog leadership reversed findings of draft report into ABC Four Corners program, FoI documents reveal

Communications watchdog leadership reversed findings of draft report into ABC Four Corners program, FoI documents reveal

An investigation by staff of the Australian Media and Communications Authority (Acma) cleared an ABC Four Corners program over its War Memorial reporting – only for the draft report findings to be reversed by the regulator’s leadership, freedom of information documents reveal.Internal correspondence shows the 11th hour backflip forced a “retrofit” of the report which initially said: “Staff are of the preliminary view that the program did not breach the impartiality provision of the [ABC] code [of conduct] with respect to this allegation.”In September the ABC’s managing director, Hugh Marks, rebuked the Acma after its finding was published, arguing its criticism of the program about the redevelopment of the Australian War Memorial was unfair and could have a chilling impact on investigative journalism in Australia.“It also unfairly impugns the integrity of the reporter and fails to acknowledge the great efforts made by the program team to ensure impartiality,” the ABC said.The Australian War Memorial initially complained to the ABC, but its concerns were dismissed by the broadcaster’s independent ombudsman and the chair of the memorial’s council, Kim Beazley, made a formal complaint to Acma which found in its favour.According to the FOI, first reported by the ABC’s Media Watch, the Acma board’s decision to go against the recommendation prompted a staffer to reply: “In trying to retrofit the additional arguments into the existing report, there are probably a few places where we’ve ended up repeating some points and could tighten the report up”.The Acma board had passed on feedback during the investigation that they weren’t quite sure the draft report “captures the vibe… that this reporting skirted a fine line” and that they can be “a bit critical”. Most of the documents revealed by the FOI appear to accept the investigation’s findings but encourage more critical language.An Acma spokesperson said the FOI documents “include informal exchanges between colleagues” and should not be viewed in isolation.Notes from an internal meeting in January include: “Are the concerns bad enough to be a breach? Probably not.”Another note says: “On balance there’s not a breach but ABC could have done more to make it clearer”.But in March 2026 notes from a board meeting say the members of the authority “found that the ABC breached the impartiality provision of the ABC Code of Practice 2024 in relation to [the episode Sacrifice]”.The FOI documents reveal several draft reports written by specialised regulatory staff backed the reporting of Gold Walkley award-winning journalist Mark Willacy, including that “impartiality does not require that every perspective receives equal time, or that every facet of every issue is presented”.“Although the ordinary reasonable viewer may consider the program was critical about how the [redevelopment] project was conducted, there is no evidence that the program was partial to critics of the project”, the draft report said.Announcing the finding in September, Acma chair Nerida O’Loughlin said the ABC must present contentious issues with due impartiality and provide audiences with sufficient context.“We found that the cumulative effect of the program’s framing, its use of strong and emotive language and its selection and differing treatment of interviewees unduly favoured critics of the redevelopment,” O’Loughlin said.A former member of the authority told the Guardian there is often debate between authority members and staff over contentious issues but reversing an investigation finding was “pretty rare”.Acma said investigations are “a collective and consultative process” and are ultimately decided by the six authority [board] members.“The Acma stands by its decision that the Four Corners ‘Sacrifice’ program did not comply with the ABC’s own impartiality standards, a spokesman said. “The Authority reached its decision after considering the program, the original complaint, the ABC’s submissions and the analysis and advice developed during the investigation,” they said.The ABC declined to comment on the FOI report and referred to its original statement.“The ABC stands behind the team, the processes that were followed and the program as broadcast,” the statement said.

Original Source

Read the full article at Theguardian →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.