Chris Minns’ underquoting backflip might have earned him a nickname that sticks

Chris Minns’ underquoting backflip might have earned him a nickname that sticks

OpinionState political editorNovember 19, 2026 — 5:00amNovember 19, 2026 — 5:00amThe impression voters have of political leaders takes a while to solidify. Scott Morrison carefully curated an image of himself as an everyman suburban dad until the schtick wore off and “Scotty from Marketing” emerged. Anthony Albanese was “Albo”, the honest broker who believed kindness was virtue. But a series of broken promises and a tendency to skirt the truth have taken the gloss off.For the past four years, Premier Chris Minns has been a pragmatic, sensible centrist whose political instincts have been near unquestionable in the cloistered world of NSW politics. But as parliament prepares to rise for the final time this term before next year’s election, we’re getting a hint of what the Minns voters might eventually see. A series of policy backflips, most recently on underquoting reforms, risk painting a picture of a leader who values style over substance and is willing to throw his colleagues under the bus when he needs to.The decision to scrap the underquoting changes literally hours before they were due to take effect is perhaps the most flagrant example of how attuned Minns is to the conservative media cycle.Kate GeraghtyMinns first raised the prospect of nixing the underquoting laws on Monday, saying real estate agents in his seat of Kogarah had raised concerns. The identities of these local agents have yet to emerge, but The Herald has been asking around. What we do know is that for at least a month, stakeholders had actually been asking the government to scrap a limited aspect of the reforms — changes prohibiting owners from dropping their price guide below an offer they had previously rejected — because of the downturn in the housing market.No one, the opposition’s fair trading spokesman Tim James noted on Tuesday, had been seeking the wholesale overturn of the reform package.“There was broadly an acceptance that underquoting remained a persistent problem in the real estate market, no matter the dynamics of the market,” he said. “This was fixable.”Their requests fell on deaf ears until conservative radio station 2GB, the heartbeat of NSW Labor under Minns, started talking about it. This is not a new phenomenon. The most persistent criticism of Labor this term has been that it is a do-nothing government. Win the day. Worry about the consequences later.But the decision to scrap the underquoting changes literally hours before they were due to take effect is perhaps the most flagrant example of how attuned Minns is to the conservative media cycle.The first words Opposition Leader Kellie Sloane uttered about the backflip on Tuesday were “government by 2GB”. It didn’t sound like a canned line, just a natural observation (she was speaking on 2GB, obviously).Perhaps what is different about this backflip from others, such as changes to reusable coffee cups that Minns nixed last month (also after uproar on 2GB), is that while 11th-hour changes to policy are obviously a bad way to run a government, it’s not even clear that this is good politics. It seems Minns did not want to be attached to anything which voters might associate with the cooling housing market. He has also quite obviously been clearing off the barnacles ahead of the election, wanting to limit One Nation and the Coalition’s ammunition against him.But if Labor had been able to choose a vibe to end the parliamentary term, panicked backflips probably wouldn’t have been it. And, more importantly, it’s unclear who this was for. There may have been an issue with the reforms; preventing owners from adjusting their price guide below an offer they’d previously rejected makes less sense in a housing downturn than it did previously. But think about the constituency of that issue for a moment. Is there a horde of home owners angry they can’t offload their Kogarah properties at a discount?Price guides, as we know, are not indicative of what an owner actually wants. No matter how severe the downturn in the market, the number of vendors keen to lower their asking price from that already inflated point to below what they originally wanted is likely to be small. The proportion of those angry enough about it to change their vote away from Labor? Vanishing, I’d suspect.Sure, there would have been a scare campaign, but, truly, if the Labor Party has reached the point where it is not game enough to gear up for a fight with real estate agents and the lobbyists who represent them, then it might be time to pack up and go home.The coda to this is the strange politics at play with Fair Trading Minister Anoulack Chanthivong. As the Herald has been reporting, Chanthivong’s future has been under a cloud for some time. Having lost support from stakeholders, colleagues and his own local branch members in Macquarie Fields, it looked increasingly like the party was not willing to step in to save him. Minns – who has made a series of captain’s calls on candidates – had declined to rescue him and, as recently as Monday, refused to publicly back him.That changed after the premier rolled him on the underquoting laws (not the first time or even second time he’s done so). A senior Labor source told the Herald that while it was not a quid pro quo, there was a recognition that he had “done the right thing” and had been “humiliated enough”.On Wednesday, after the dust had settled on the underquoting saga, the two men appeared together at a press conference, striking a not-very-convincing tone of bonhomie as Minns offered Chanthivong his support.Minns trusts his political instincts implicitly. Perhaps they were telling him that knifing a minister after dragging him through a public embarrassment was going too far.Michael McGowan is state political editor for The Sydney Morning Herald.Get a weekly wrap of views that will challenge, champion and inform your own. Sign up for our Opinion newsletter.More:NSW State ParliamentOpinionFor subscribersNSW residential propertyChris MinnsResidential propertyKellie SloaneFrom our partners

Original Source

Read the full article at Smh →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.