Cheap £2.99 supermarket own-brand cheese named better than Cathedral City and M&S

Cheap £2.99 supermarket own-brand cheese named better than Cathedral City and M&S

Cheap £2.99 supermarket own-brand cheese named better than Cathedral City and M&S | Senior Lifestyle Reporter Published November 17, 2026 3:51pm Updated November 17, 2026 3:51pm The best cheese has been revealed (Picture: Getty Images) Big brand food names don’t always deliver the best flavour. We’ve seen £2.49 supermarket own-brand sausages beat M&S and Jolly Hog, plus McVitie’s lose out to M&S in a chocolate digestive comparison. Now, a new blind taste test has revealed the bargain cheddar that’s rated higher than Cathedral City —just in time to stock up for the Christmas cheese board. Consumer experts at Which? Brought together 75 cheese lovers to conduct a big taste test, pitting supermarket own-brand cheeses from the likes of Tesco, M&S, Lidl, and Sainsbury’s against big names. And the winner might surprise you, as it was Aldi’s product that beat out the likes of Pilgrims Choice and Castello to come out on top. The cheap cheese was crowned the winner (Picture: Aldi/Which?) Aldi’s Specially Selected West Country Extra Mature Cheddar (£2.99 for 350g) was named the winner, earning an overall score of 78 per cent. Three quarters of the panel thought the cheddar’s colour ‘looked the part’, and they loved the ‘smooth, firm, and creamy’ texture. The cheese’s salt levels were also top notch, and the majority of people agreed the strength of flavour was ‘just right’. All of this meant Aldi’s product was deemed a ‘crowd-pleasing best buy’ and as one of the cheapest cheeses in the test, it also earned a great value accolade. How did other cheeses fare? Pilgrims Choice was the highest scoring brand (Picture: Pilgrims Choice/Which?) Ask Metro Use AI to go deeper into the stories you care about – powered by Metro and trusted publications. It was a branded cheese that came next, with Pilgrims Choice Extra Mature Cheddar (£4.25 for 350g) taking second place and being branded a ‘best buy’. It beat competition from fellow brands Cathedral City and Castello, scoring highly for its flavour, smoothness, creaminess, and firmness. The ‘good-looking’ cheese was also deemed to have the right level of saltiness, but some tasters said they would have liked a little more ‘crumble’. Then came Waitrose Davidstow Cornish Extra Mature Cheddar (£4.25 for 250g) with a score of 75 per cent. This cheddar was described as ‘appetising-looking’ with ‘perfect’ salt levels and a creamy texture. Along with the first two, it also earned a ‘best buy’ award, being deemed a ‘worthy mid-range cheddar’. Waitrose came in third place (Picture: Waitrose/Which?) Cathedral City Our Extra Mature Cheddar (£3.50 for 250g) was in fourth place in the rankings, scoring 74 percent. The panel described it as a ‘solid all-rounder’, rating it highly for its appearance, saltiness, smoothness, firmness, and creaminess. However, the cheese lost some points for its strength of flavour, as some wanted it to be stronger. Additionally, others would have liked a ‘crumblier texture’. Morrisons The Best Extra Mature Farmhouse Cheddar (£3.50 for 300g) also scored 74 per cent, as did Sainsbury’s Taste The Difference Extra Mature Cumbrian Cheddar (£3.95 for 350g). Cathedral City was in fourth place (Picture: Cathedral City/Ocado) Lidl Deluxe Somerset Crunchy Extra Mature Cheddar (£2.99 for 350g) was close behind these, followed by Asda Exceptional Wyke Farms Somerset Extra Mature Cheddar (£3.25 for 300g), and Marks & Spencer Cornish Cruncher Extra Mature Cheddar (£5.25 for 300g). And rounding out the test were Castello Tickler Extra Mature Cheddar (£4.50 for 300g), which scored 69 per cent, and Tesco Finest Cave Aged Cheddar (£3.50 for 200g), with a score of 66 per cent. The Castello cheddar was praised for its ‘colour, smoothness, and firmness’, but failed to wow with its flavour, while Tesco’s cheese was ‘not a big hit’, with less than half of the panel liking the flavour. Which cheese is your favourite? Sign up to Metro's The Slice newsletter for your guide to what's on in London, with trusted reviews, offers and giveaways. How was the cheese tested? A panel of 75 people tested the cheese in a blind taste test which took place in September 2026. The group consisted of people who regularly buy and eat cheddar and were a mix of various ages and genders. Each of the cheeses was tried in a private booth, so no one could discuss their thoughts or be influenced by anyone else. All of the cheddars were then rated on taste, texture, aroma, and appearance, with each person sharing what they liked and didn’t like. The final scores were based on 50% flavour, 20% aroma, 15% appearance, and 15% texture. Cheddar cheese ranking from the blind taste test: Aldi Specially Selected West Country Extra Mature Cheddar, £2.99 for 350g, 78 per cent Pilgrims Choice Extra Mature Cheddar, £4.25 for 350g, 76 per cent Waitrose Davidstow Cornish Extra Mature Cheddar, £4.25 for 350g, 75 per cent Cathedral City Our Extra Mature Cheddar, £3.50 for 350g, 74 per cent Morrisons The Best Extra Mature Farmhouse Cheddar, £3.50 for 300g, 74 per cent Sainsbury’s Taste The Difference Extra Mature Cumbrian Cheddar, £3.95 for 350g, 74 per cent Lidl Deluxe Somerset Crunchy Extra Mature Cheddar, £2.99 for 350g, 73 per cent Asda Exceptional Wyke Farms Somerset Extra Mature Cheddar, £3.52 for 300g, 72 per cent Marks & Spencer Cornish Cruncher Extra Mature Cheddar, £5.25 for 300g, 70 per cent Castello Tickler Extra Mature Cheddar, £4.50 for 300g, 69 per cent Tesco Finest Cave Aged Cheddar, £3.50 for 200g, 66 per cent More top-tasting supermarket products If you’re looking for some of the best items you can buy in the supermarket, here’s a selection of other taste tests Metro has covered recently: Supermarket Christmas pudding officially crowned better than M&S — and it’s £5 cheaper ‘Velvety’ hot chocolate sold in supermarkets crowned better than M&S and Knoops Cheap £1.99 supermarket own-brand Yorkshire puddings officially crowned better than Aunt Bessie’s Cheap 59p supermarket tomato soup that beats Heinz in taste This story was first published on May 3, 2026. It has since been updated with new scores. Do you have a story you’d like to share? Get in touch by emailing MetroLifestyleTeam@metro.co.uk Deals of the Day The best Black Friday beauty deals on the Dr Barbara Sturm face cream and hyaluronic serum The best Black Friday sleep deals to upgrade your bedroom with Simba’s 33% off sale Why shoppers are rushing to snap up this 99p Audible deal before Christmas 14,500 five-star reviews later, this cult sleep spray is discounted for Black Friday Shoppers ditch expensive dental work for these £19.99 MySweetSmile whitening strips Arrow MORE: McDonald’s unveils Christmas menu for 2026 with Home Alone ‘adult Happy Meal’ Arrow MORE: M&S has seen your ‘gross’ cake complaints and has something to say Arrow MORE: Middle class Brits in uproar at Maldon Sea Salt import ‘scandal’ The Slice Your free newsletter guide to the best London has on offer, from drinks deals to restaurant reviews.

Original Source

Read the full article at Metro →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.