Gwen Stefani’s GXVE Beauty is gone. So are Scarlett Johansson‘s skin care line The Outset and Serena Williams’ Wyn Beauty cosmetics. Even Kim Kardashian‘s KKW Beauty and SKKN by Kim have been retired. Blake Lively‘s Blake Brown Beauty hair care is struggling, and Jennifer Lopez‘s JLO Beauty has quietly exited Sephora. Yes, the celebrity beauty business is crowded and unforgiving, but that still hasn’t stopped Cardi B and Jennifer Lawrence from joining the fray. Cardi B, for one, remains undeterred. “People are always going to have something to say, but I didn’t create Grow-Good just to put my name on a bottle. Hair care has always been personal to me. I’ve been sharing my hair routines, my homemade treatments and my hair journey with my fans for years, way before I ever thought about launching a brand.” Blake Lively Blake Brown Beauty With a stake in a brand worth potentially far more than a movie deal as production slates threaten to continue shrinking, it’s easy to understand why Hollywood keeps lining up. The success stories are seductive: Rihanna‘s Fenty Beauty helped make her a billionaire, Selena Gomez‘s Rare Beauty has been valued at $2.7 billion, and Hailey Bieber’s Rhode sold to e.l.f. Beauty in a deal worth up to $1 billion. Selena Gomez’s Rare Beauty, valued at $2.7 billion, is an increasingly rare example of wild success in a crowded market. But fame doesn’t always bring fortune — or an easy ride. In October, Lawrence launched Mes (pronounced “mess”) with Arcaea CEO Jasmina Aganovic, generating plenty of buzz and a fair amount of backlash over what online critics complained was another example of celebrity overreach. The partnership reportedly began after Lawrence watched Aganovic deliver a TED Talk about the future of cosmetics. Aganovic leads Arcaea, a biotech company developing sustainable, high-performance cosmetic ingredients that has counted Chanel among its investors, and she brings serious beauty credentials, having previously worked at Living Proof and led skin-microbiome brand Mother Dirt. Mes embraces an “unbothered beauty” philosophy, with the enticing promise of achieving great hair without putting in lots of time or effort. It also plays into Lawrence’s public persona as the rare A-lister with genuinely self-deprecating, what-you-see-is-what-you-get candor. The actress introduced the line, which includes a hair mask, serum and volume mist, on Instagram as one for “nice people who don’t leave mean comments.” It was almost as if she knew what was coming. (Per her reps, Lawrence was not available to comment for this report.) After years away from social media, Lawrence made her debut Sept. 9, just weeks before the launch, and the timing didn’t go unnoticed. Some commenters smelled a calculated sales pitch. Others questioned the fit, noting she’s never been especially known for her hair. To skeptics and Reddit users, it looked like one more celebrity chasing a Rhode-sized payday. Lawrence, for her part, said the line grew out of years in the glam chair, when she would wash her hair only once a week. “At this point in the life cycle of celebrity brands, the initial reaction is always going be the eye roll,” says Aliza Licht, marketing veteran and author of On Brand. “We all have the playbook now and everybody knows what’s behind the curtain.” Often, that’s a licensing deal, a manufacturer, a hefty marketing budget and a carefully crafted backstory, with the star’s name as the cherry on top. “Consumers are good at recognizing an engineered marketing narrative dressed up as a personal passion project.” Kim Kardashian SKKN Stefanie Keenan/Getty Images Beauty publicist Marie-Laure Fournier, founder of Fournier PR + Consulting, believes the criticism around Mes is still manageable. “A candid, even humorous video with Aganovic, whether with a magazine or on social media, could go a long way toward humanizing the launch and addressing the skepticism head on,” she says. “The public wants to see that you’re listening, learning and willing to adapt.” Despite some of the backlash, the early industry read on Mes is cautiously optimistic. Lawrence’s working with Aganovic is “a good move, to partner with a brand like Arcaea that is well established in the beauty industry,” says Clare Hennigan, principal analyst for beauty and consumer goods at global research firm Mintel. Hennigan also sees promise in the products, particularly a gel hair mask that can be applied to dry hair and doubles as a styler. No need to wait for wash day. “They are solving a pain point of convenience, a key motivator for purchases,” she says. “Anything that makes life a little easier is something shoppers will pay more for.” Kate Hudson would applaud this solution-oriented approach for the consumer. The celebrity entrepreneur co-founded Fabletics in 2013, remains a shareholder and watched the activewear company reportedly surpass $1 billion in revenue in 2025. “You can have the most beautiful vision in the world, but once you put something out there, you have to pay attention to what they need, what they love and what they don’t,” she says. Jennifer Lawrence’s Mes hair care line was met with skepticism. Delivering effective products is one thing; fostering a genuine connection with the consumer is another. Cardi B out of the gate demonstrated a keen understanding of the latter with marketing Grow-Good. Her grassroots strategy focuses on neighborhood beauty supply stores, including shops in her native Bronx. The hair care line, following three years of development, debuted in April and reportedly sold out in less than 35 minutes. “Listen, I know my people because I am my people!” she says. “I grew up going to beauty supply stores. Those stores have always been part of our community, and I wanted Grow-Good to be there too. For me, it was about making sure the products were accessible to the people I created them for.” Lisa Motzko Hamilton, former vp of merchandising at Ulta Beauty and co-founder of Breakthru Beauty consultancy, says brands perform best when the entertainer is “showing up, engaging with their community and sharing a part of themselves beyond their celebrity status.” The Business of Fashion reports a promising 40 percent return-customer rate for Grow-Good. Even more critically, the celebrity and the product need to make sense together. Lady Gaga’s Haus Labs cosmetics draw on her reputation for artistry and creative expression, while Selena Gomez built Rare Beauty around supporting mental health for young people, a cause she has publicly owned as a personal issue, with 1 percent of sales going to Rare Impact Fund. Hennigan cites Jennifer Aniston‘s LolaVie as a brand that gets it very right. Aniston’s hairstyles have been a cultural fixture for decades, making hair care a natural fit. She spent several years developing the line before launching in 2021 and has since expanded to Ulta and Credo. “LolaVie is very personal to me. My relationship with my hair, the products I’ve tried over the years and the challenges I’ve experienced are what inspired the brand in the first place,” says Aniston. “I didn’t want to simply put my name on something; I wanted to be part of building something that I truly believed in.” Jennifer Aniston’s LolaVie hair care line has staying power, partially because she keeps herself connected to consumers: “We’ve made changes to product based on feedback.” The Morning Show star also makes a point of keeping a conversation going with customers. “I love hearing how other people incorporate the products into their routines and about the results they’re seeing. We’ve made changes to product in the past based on consumer feedback,” she says. (She’s also extended LolaVie into pet shampoo: “My dogs are such a big part of my family, and I wanted to bring the same thoughtfulness and attention to detail that goes into our human hair care.” All profits benefit The Clydeo Fund, which supports animal rescue and rehabilitation.) Author Licht points to Kardashian as someone who has spent years cultivating “a parasocial bond with followers, so a new brand lands with people she already knows, even the haters.” Stars who suddenly surface hawking new products are a harder sell. “It’s odd when we hear from celebrities out of the blue,” she says. “We don’t have social relationships with them, they’re movie stars.” Licht adds that Lawrence, who had no public social media presence until weeks before the launch, “seemed to come out of thin air,” she says. “We are missing a bit of evidence there.” Scarlett Johansson The Outset Ilya S. Savenok/Getty Images Johansson’s The Outset offers another cautionary tale. “We didn’t have historical commentary from Scarlett around skin care,” says Licht. “The consumer needs to find a germ of a connection between the celebrity and the brand.” Hennigan sees another issue: “The problem was proof. The efficacy and science may not have been as visible to shoppers.” Lopez faced a different kind of disconnect with potential consumers. A merchandising executive at a beauty retailer, speaking on condition of anonymity, questions JLO Beauty’s origin story. “Jennifer hung the age-defying ‘JLo Glow’ on a family olive oil secret, but doubters online, including a chorus of dermatologists, weren’t convinced it was the whole story with JLO Beauty,” creating an issue with consumer trust. Jennifer Lopez JLO Beauty AaronP/Bauer-Griffin/GC Images/Getty Images Blake Lively’s Blake Brown Beauty hair care line launched to considerable fanfare at Target, only to face a more complicated reality as the actress became embroiled in the fallout surrounding It Ends With Us and her legal battle with Justin Baldoni. Lively went quiet on social media, and sales have reportedly dropped sharply. “The war with Justin was likely a huge detriment to sales,” says Licht. Distribution matters, too. Lady Gaga’s Haus Labs initially launched exclusively on Amazon, a challenging fit for color cosmetics, where shoppers want to try on shades before buying. Its move to Sephora introduced the brand to a broader beauty audience. Then comes the most important question of all: Does the world really need another beauty line? Gwen Stefani GXVE Beauty Fenty Beauty answered that question nearly a decade ago with an expansive and inclusive shade range that addressed a glaring gap in the cosmetics market. Rhode found its opening with accessible pricing on ingredients that had become associated with more expensive skin care. “Peptides were drawing a lot of attention, with many brands charging a premium for them, while Bieber offered high-performing peptide products at a more affordable price,” notes Hennigan. For Mes, even in light of its messy debut, Hennigan sees an opportunity to shift the conversation toward time-saving efficiency with education: “Help consumers understand how these products fit into their existing hair care routines. Since the hair mask comes with a learning curve, the brand needs to drive the how-to aspect home” with tutorials and partnerships with pro stylists who can demo the products, she advises. Ultimately, the biggest challenge of the enterprise may be the least glamorous part: remaining involved long after the cameras and launch parties. Hudson, who joined HealthyCell supplements as an investor and creative strategy partner in October, says patience is the X factor. “I’ve learned that building a business is a long game,” she says. “You have to love the process, not just the excitement of launching something.” Licht doesn’t mince words: “Most of the time celebrities are just not cut out for the daily grind required to build a brand, and that’s why a lot of these lines fail.” Additional reporting by Beth Landman. This story appeared in the Nov. 18 issue of The Hollywood Reporter magazine. Click here to subscribe.
Celebrity Beauty Brands (Even Kim’s) Are Failing. Here Are the New Rules
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Hollywoodreporter →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.