Analysis - Legacy is important to Dave Rennie.It is said that the All Blacks head coach was determined to bring back some of the traditions that disappeared from the group under previous coach Scott Robertson (and which some former players were surprised by), so Rennie will be feeling this historic defeat to Wales more than most.It should go without saying but Rennie has promised to be rigorous in his review of what was a catastrophic failure in Cardiff including the selections for the test and the timing of his substitutions.Again, this hardly needs spelling out but the All Blacks' preparations for their next test against England at Twickenham on Sunday morning NZT will be very different after this 35-28 humbling - famously Wales' first win over New Zealand in 73 years.There will be an extra edge (along with several changes in personnel), but that should reinforce the main point of Rennie's review.Yes, Wales thoroughly deserved their win by attacking with a ruthlessness that escaped the All Blacks and then defending with an astonishing bravery and energy, but how much did complacency play a part in the All Blacks' failure?And, further, how much did they buy into their own hype at Principality Stadium which featured the smallest crowd attendance for such a fixture?Just over 56,000 turned up to a place with a capacity of more than 70,000 which suggested that the confidence of the home side's supporters was at an all-time low.Here are five other takeaways of a result which shocked the rugby world:1. Decision makingThis was the biggest failure. According to Rennie, the All Blacks turned over the ball nine times in the first half and four of them came from attempting offloads. His men have been given free rein to play with an optimistic mindset but that does not necessarily mean trying to score with every possession.Even their most experienced players, including former skipper Scott Barrett, was at fault.In the second half they went too far the other way and thought they could crash through the middle of the Wales defence without passing the ball.Quinn Tupaea is well wrapped up by the Welsh defence at Principality Stadium.Matt Impey / www.photosport.nzA wider, more detached view would have seen the acres of space available away from the breakdown.Instead, they narrowed their focus and paid the price. That did not reflect well on the team's decision makers including lock Barrett, main playmaker Richie Mo'unga and captain Beauden Barrett.2. SelectionsRennie and his selectors made 10 changes to the team that beat Scotland, including eight to the starting line-up.The word was that the team trained well during the week but clearly not under the sort of pressure that Wales exerted. That is probably to be expected but some combinations clearly did not work.Yes, Rennie and company had to give game time to all the squad at some point on the tour, but so many changes at once clearly affected his team's balance and performance.One wonders, for example, if halfback Cam Roigard would have provided No.10 Mo'unga, playing only his second test in three years, with more time and space than Cortez Ratima. Which brings us to the next point:3. Gulf in classThe coaches have said before and after this loss that there isn't much between many of their players in terms of ability but that doesn't bear scrutiny.There is a gulf between Roigard and the rest at halfback and the same goes for second-five Jordie Barrett and right wing Will Jordan, all three of whom were badly missed in Cardiff. Codie Taylor's leadership in the front row (and accurate lineout throwing) was also missed.Halfback Cam Roigard was badly missed by the All Blacks against Wales.David Neilson / www.photosport.nzDamian McKenzie has his detractors but it became abundantly clear why Rennie rates him so highly. Remarkably, this was the first test in a streak of 39, going back to the 2023 World Cup knockout stage, that McKenzie has missed. If anything, he enhanced his reputation by not being involved in this one.Fehi Fineanganofo scored a well-taken try in Cardiff in what was his first test, but he was exposed too often defensively and, with Jordan potentially gone for the year due to his hamstring strain, wings are an area of weakness for the All Blacks.4. SubstitutionsLeicester Fainga'anuku's selection as a "hybrid" player on the bench, one capable of playing loose forward or midfielder/wing, appeared a positive and progression move. But the way he was used in this test compounded the problems for the All Blacks.Rennie said afterwards that he elected to replace No.8 Wallace Sititi, one of his team's best alongside flanker Peter Lakai, with Fainga'anuku with 16 minutes remaining because of Sititi's workload.Wales celebrate another defensive win - this time holding up Leicester Fainga'anuku over the tryline.Matt Impey / www.photosport.nzOne of Fainga'anuku's strengths as a loose forward is his attacking threat close to the breakdown - but, as mentioned, this was precisely what the All Blacks did not need as they laid siege to the Welsh line while ignoring space elsewhere.Fainga'anuku was one of three New Zealand players held up over the tryline. In his case, an offload earlier to Rieko Ioane may have unlocked the defence.Mo'unga and replacement prop Xavier Numia also ignored unmarked players outside them. In Numia's case it would have taken a miracle for the Welsh to have stopped Quinn Tupaea crash over the line.The use of Fainga'anuku is one of several aspects of a substitution strategy that did not work.5. C-wordConsistency, or more accurately, inconsistency, is an issue that haunted the All Blacks under previous coach Robertson and it appears here to stay under Rennie. For all of the reasons above.Bonus extra: 'Humbleness'A personal plea: no more social media videos of the All Blacks sweeping out their dressing rooms because after all these years it just comes across as performative and, to be frank, cringeworthy.After this loss most of their supporters would have preferred to see them practising ruck cleans rather than floor cleans.
'Catastrophic failure': Five takeaways from the All Blacks' shock loss to Wales
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Rnz →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.