Magnus Carlsen is now a fatherNEW DELHI: In the lastest episode of the ongoing sagas of grandmasters not showing up to the games during Total Chess Pilot event in Budapest, Hungary, Magnus Carlsen's decision to forfeit two Rapid games against Vladislav Artemiev on Thursday has sparked debate across the chess fraternity.While some players understand his decision, others have questioned the sportsmanship and fairness of choosing which games to play while a match remains undecided.From Russian Grandmaster Ian Nepomniachtchi calling for expulsion to India's Viswanathan Anand pointing out a loophole in the rules, here is what prominent chess figures have said about the controversy.Vladislav Artemiev: "It's a little bit strange"Carlsen's opponent, Vladislav Artemiev, offered a relatively understanding reaction to the forfeits.While admitting that the situation felt unusual, he also acknowledged that players could be tired towards the end of a demanding tournament."Personally, for me, I can understand this possibility and this choice. Honestly, I'm a little bit tired at the end of the tournament, and this possibility is not so bad. But it's a little bit strange," Artemiev told ChessBase.Ian Nepomniachtchi: "The player has to be expelled"Ian Nepomniachtchi took a much stronger position on the incident, believing that Carlsen's decision warranted serious disciplinary action."I think the player has to be expelled from the tournament," Nepomniachtchi said, reacting to Carlsen forfeiting both Rapid games against Artemiev.Fabiano Caruana: "This is even worse"Fabiano Caruana was critical of Carlsen's decision, particularly because the Norwegian skipped the Rapid games in the middle of an ongoing match rather than withdrawing from the entire contest."I don't think it's good at all. I don't think it was good the first time when Magnus decided not to play after he had won the match... but this is even worse because you are leaving in the middle of the match! I think you should just forfeit the match if you don't play. But this is also I think even worse because you're kind of leaving in the middle of the match. That's my view and also it kind of inspired other players to start leaving their games which is not," Caruana said.Anish Giri: "I'm too old for these shenanigans"Anish Giri made it clear that he would not follow the same approach, even in light of Carlsen's earlier decisions to skip games during the tournament."One thing for sure, I wouldn't dare to do it myself, even after what Magnus did. I'm too old for these shenanigans," Giri told ChessBase.Viswanathan Anand: "I wouldn't even have realised that it was possible"FIDE Deputy President and five-time World Champion Viswanathan Anand highlighted what he believes is a loophole in the Total Chess format.While he acknowledged that skipping a game after a match has already been decided can happen in sport, he questioned the decision to sit out individual games when the overall result is still up for grabs."It's like a game day, and my instinct is I will go and play. I would have mumbled, I would have complained, but I wouldn't have," Anand told Indian journalists, as reported by The Indian Express.Speaking about the possibility of doing the same himself, Anand, as reported by Sportstar, added, "I wouldn't even have realised that it was possible to do such a thing."Anand also questioned the broader implications of allowing players to choose which games they participate in."We are now in a situation where a player is just deciding which games he is going to play and which he isn't. And the match has not been decided at all," he added.He described the situation as a "gap in the rules" and said the regulations would need tightening.Among the possible solutions he suggested were additional prize money for players who complete the final games and financial penalties for forfeiting them.What exactly happened in Budapest?The controversy unfolded during the knockout stage of the Total Chess World Championship Tour Pilot, where each two-player contest features four Blitz games, two Rapid games and one Fast Classic game.Carlsen had previously skipped both Fast Classic games against Bibisara Assaubayeva after securing the day's result on consecutive days.However, his decision against Artemiev was different. After playing all four Blitz games on Thursday, he forfeited both Rapid games despite the match for 17th place remaining undecided.He subsequently returned for the Fast Classic, which he won, taking the day's contest 11-9.Explaining his decision, Carlsen told Norway's TV 2 that he would rather be better rested for the classical game.ALSO READ: In the land of Frankenstein, Gukesh asked to distance himself from 'what people are saying' ahead of World Chess ChampionshipThe incidents involving Carlsen, Abhimanyu Mishra and Richard Rapport have prompted questions about the format's regulations.Anand believes the rules need to be tightened, while organisers have said they will gather feedback from players, arbiters and other stakeholders before the full tour begins in March 2027.
Carlsen's forfeit controversy: Anand, Giri and other top Grandmasters react
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Timesofindia →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.