Politics Forget the Blue Wave. Could We Be In For a Blue Decade? If Democrats really use the power they’ve just won, they could dominate the next 10 years of American politics. Here’s how. Photo illustration by Slate. Photos by Getty Images Plus. Sign up for the Slatest to get the most insightful analysis, criticism, and advice out there, delivered to your inbox daily. For many Democrats, the past 10 years of American politics have felt like one long 2016. Donald Trump solidified his position as the decade’s dominant political figure, including during the four-year interregnum that followed his loss to Joe Biden. Then there’s the continual relitigation of the nasty 2016 presidential primary between Hillary Clinton and Bernie Sanders, creating divisions between moderates and progressives that have left the party bickering internally despite being embattled from without. More broadly, 2016 was also the year that brought about a less principled and more authoritarian Republican Party, a hyperconservative Supreme Court, and the decline of American power abroad—an unpleasant asylum we’ve all been living in since. The ongoing political hangover from that one November night in 2016 may be one reason why some Democrats quickly moved to temper the euphoria that followed this month’s midterm elections. And sure, despite the party’s sizable new congressional majorities, Democrats will probably be able to achieve little of substance as long as Trump remains in the White House. The president may be a lame duck, but his 10-year stranglehold on American life has made it difficult to picture a political universe that revolves around anyone else. More than anything, an earned wariness of imagination explains the collective reluctance to extrapolate too grandly from the results. “This was a repudiation, not a vindication,” Rahm Emanuel, the former Chicago mayor and a likely 2028 presidential candidate, cautioned his party. But sometimes the long view is worth entertaining. And as the dust settles and the final races are called, it’s starting to become possible to discern the beginnings of a path out of our decade-long national nightmare. The depth and breadth of Democrats’ victories have the potential to reshape the presidency, Congress, the federal judiciary, and even the map of the country in ways that could benefit the party well beyond the next two years. Politics rarely offers guarantees; the midterms themselves are evidence of how quickly the political ground can shift, especially for politicians who misread the forces that swept them into office. Yet for those willing to see them, the conditions are there for 2026 to become the year that jump-started a much more liberal and democratically healthy decade, bringing the long 2016 to a decisive end and inaugurating a blue new chapter in American political life. Let’s explore the land of possibility. Congress Americans are currently not huge fans of what is happening on Capitol Hill. Since 2016, voters have tried almost every conceivable governing arrangement and eventually rejected all of them. We’ve had a Republican president with unified control of Congress, then a Democratic president with the same thing. We’ve had Democrats controlling the House while Republicans controlled the Senate, then Republicans controlling the House while Democrats controlled the Senate. Voters chose to pair a Republican president with a Democratic Congress this time, but it stands to reason that they’ll eventually tire of that arrangement too. As Democratic strategist Lis Smith told Fox News last week, “You rent voters, you don’t own them.” But Democrats’ dominance in this month’s elections have laid a plausible foundation for the party to enjoy a longer-than-normal lease—along with sizable congressional majorities for years to come. Let’s start with the Senate. Elections are cumulative: If Democrats had failed to defend seats in states Kamala Harris lost in 2024, their incoming Senate majority would be four seats smaller. Likewise, future elections offer a chance to build on this year’s gains. Democrats overcame daunting odds to win 56 seats this month, and 2028 is already looking like the party’s most favorable map in decades. Yes, they’ll have to defend seats in five states Trump won in 2024: Arizona, Georgia, Nevada, Ohio, and Pennsylvania. Yet Democrats have managed to win Senate seats and governorships in each during the Trump era so far. Republicans, meanwhile, will have to defend Senate seats in six states where Democrats just won big—Wisconsin, North Carolina, Alaska, Kansas, Iowa, and South Carolina—and two more, Florida and Louisiana, where Democrats came tantalizingly close. “Some of the very same states where we won this election will offer new opportunities to expand our majority in 2028,” Chuck Schumer, the likely next Senate majority leader, told the Washington Post. The prospect of holding on to the Senate for multiple cycles matters because it has in recent years been the far harder chamber of Congress for Democrats to win. Some of that is down to the institution’s design, which gives equal weight to rural, relatively underpopulated states that tend to vote Republican. But the good news for Democrats is that Senate majorities, once won, tend to be sticky. Unlike the House, which subjects all 435 members to the will of the voters every two years, only a third of the chamber is up for reelection at a time. That fact insulates many senators from the vicissitudes of politics, meaning it often takes parties multiple cycles to dig themselves out of the minority. After Republicans lost the Senate in 2006—the most recent midterm that took place during an unpopular Republican president’s second term—eight years passed before the GOP managed to claw its way back to a majority. Bigger majorities also take longer to erode, and Democrats just won the biggest majority either party has enjoyed since Barack Obama was president. Next, the House. Partisan control of Congress’ lower chamber has ping-ponged three times in the Trump era so far, but this year’s results offer Democrats a chance to finally break the pattern. At a projected 260 seats, Democrats’ incoming House majority will be larger than any held by either party in more than three decades. It’s true that many of those seats are in Trump-won districts that could be hard for Democrats to defend in a less blue year. Yet the president and his party seem likely to remain unpopular headed into 2028, which could stem Democrats’ losses. It’s even possible that Trump could continue to boost House Democrats long after he’s out of office. The president has repelled the kinds of suburban, better-educated, and more politically engaged Americans who vote in every election, trading them in for less-engaged, working-class, and rural Americans who are less reliable votes for the GOP in nonpresidential years. If that dynamic holds, it could help Democrats hang on to the House even during bruising midterms that take place under a future president of their own party. Then there’s the not-so-small matter of what Democrats might actually do with all the seats they’ve won. Expanding their Senate majority to 60 seats or more in 2028 would let Democrats bypass the Republican filibusters that have scuttled bills aimed at expanding voting access and restoring abortion rights after the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade. There’s another possibility too: Even with fewer than 60 seats, Senate Democrats could move to modify or even abolish the filibuster for good as soon as next year. The party publicly debated doing so under Biden, only for a couple of holdouts to block the effort. It’s true that some sitting Democrats, like Sen. John Fetterman of Pennsylvania, continue to publicly support the filibuster, an accidental quirk of Senate procedure that lets a minority of senators blockade bills that lack supermajority support. It’s likely that some of Fetterman’s colleagues harbor quieter reservations too. But a simple majority of senators can effectively rewrite the chamber’s rules, and several incoming Democratic freshmen—including James Talarico of Texas and Annie Andrews of South Carolina—have already said they support some kind of reform. Filibuster reform is especially important for Democrats. Under Trump, Republicans have largely used their majorities to enact tax cuts and appoint judges, measures that aren’t subject to the filibuster’s 60-vote threshold. But the Democratic Party’s ambitions are tied up in passing big pieces of legislation that will really change things. A Democratic Senate unshackled from the filibuster could be the Senate that acts aggressively to restore abortion access nationwide, expand voting rights, ban partisan gerrymandering, curb fossil-fuel emissions, and pass other big-ticket liberal policy goals. Importantly, liberal doesn’t necessarily mean progressive; at least for now, Democrats’ majorities are heavily dependent on Trump-won states and House districts. But there may be ways for a durably Democratic Congress to change that too—perhaps by turning Puerto Rico and the District of Columbia into states. Doing so wouldn’t just give nearly 4 million Americans who currently lack voting representation in Congress a seat at the table; it would also add a handful of new senators and members of Congress, who could in turn make it easier for Democrats to win and hold the legislative branch far into the future. The Presidency In order to enact ambitious legislation, though, Democrats will need a president who’s willing to sign those bills into law. Lucky for them, both history and the results of this year’s midterms suggest that the party has a very good shot to retake the White House soon—and perhaps even hold it for much of the next decade. For one thing, Democrats have already won back the presidency once on the heels of an unpopular Trump administration. For another, Trump himself won’t be on the ballot next time. The most recent Republican who tried to succeed an unpopular, term-limited GOP president who’d started a widely disliked war was John McCain, who lost to Obama in a landslide in 2008. Three one-term presidencies in a row have made it hard to remember what it’s like for a single person to hold the Oval Office for eight consecutive years, but in the broad sweep of American history, that’s unusual: Most presidents who seek reelection end up winning. So if a Democrat does succeed Trump in two years, he or she should have a reasonable shot of holding the White House until 2037. The midterms have also unlocked opportunities for Democrats to improve their presidential odds far beyond that. The most promising is the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact—otherwise known as eliminating the Electoral College. Introduced in 2006, the compact is an agreement among states to award their presidential electors—the 538 people who technically elect the president—to the candidate who wins the national popular vote rather than just the vote in their state. So far, states collectively worth 219 electoral votes (plus another three from D.C.) have signed on to the compact, and Democrats in Pennsylvania, Michigan, Wisconsin, Arizona, and Nevada are already talking about using their new governing trifectas to join it. If they do, the compact will have enough signatories to take effect, essentially sidestepping the Electoral College. That would wreak unknown havoc on how candidates campaign for president, but there’s reason to suspect that Democrats would benefit overall. The party’s presidential candidates have lost the popular vote just twice this century, but the Electoral College has enabled Republicans to win the White House four times over the same period. (Without the Electoral College, Al Gore would have beaten George W. Bush, and Hillary Clinton would have beaten Trump, erasing the past two Republican presidencies.) There are plenty of unanswered legal questions about whether the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact will pass constitutional muster, and court cases challenging it could become more plentiful if additional states sign on. So maybe the Electoral College will remain—but regardless, the midterms have proved that Democrats have the ability to expand their political appeal enough to win it in novel ways. “The old electoral ‘Blue Wall’ strategy to 270 died Tuesday night,” wrote Democratic strategist Mike Madrid, referring to Democrats’ decades-old stratagem of securing the White House by clinching Michigan, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin. “That has been replaced by the new Southern Strategy—California, Arizona, Nevada, Texas, Georgia and North Carolina are the future.” Democrats have yet to win a couple of those states in any Trump-era presidential election, but it’s quite conceivable that they could. The party swept every statewide office on the ballot in Texas this month and won a Senate seat in North Carolina for the first time since 2008. The Judiciary Presidents are good for more than just signing legislation; they also nominate federal judges for the Senate to confirm. Thanks in part to this year’s midterms, Democrats are in a prime position to shift the federal judiciary leftward—and to begin to reverse some of the damage that a majority-Republican-appointed Supreme Court has wreaked over the past decade. Let’s start at the top. Morbid though it is, Supreme Court appointments are for life, so the actuarial tables help tell the story. The court’s oldest sitting justices are both Republican appointees: Clarence Thomas, 78, and Samuel Alito, 76. A third conservative, Chief Justice John Roberts, is 71, and Sonia Sotomayor, whom Obama appointed in 2009, is 72. If any of them were to retire or die in the next two years, it’s likely that Senate Democrats—following the precedent set by Republican Sen. Mitch McConnell, another bitter legacy of 2016—would use their new majority to block Trump from replacing them. Starting in January, Democrats can also do the same to any other lower-court judges Trump tries to appoint during the remainder of his term. And if 2026 does turn out to be a political inflection point, Democrats will be able to do more than play defense. If the party holds both the Senate and the presidency after 2028 and beyond, liberal justices could end up taking Thomas’, Alito’s, and even Roberts’ seats. That would tip what’s currently a 6–3 conservative SCOTUS in a much more liberal direction, counteracting and potentially reversing the spate of GOP-friendly rulings the court has handed down since Trump became president. A future Democratic president and Senate could do something similar to the federal judiciary writ large, which currently has a relatively even ideological split. There’s also the potential for judicial reform, like instituting term limits for Supreme Court justices or even expanding the size of the court. These possibilities are much more politically volatile—both would be hugely controversial and would almost certainly require sizable Democratic congressional majorities, plus a Democratic president. But they’re already things that ambitious Democrats are talking about heading into 2028. The States If you think 2026 was a bloodbath for Republicans in Congress, have a look at the rest of the country. When Trump was inaugurated in 2017, Democrats controlled just 16 governors’ mansions. By January, the party will control nearly twice that number. Democrats are also on track to flip more than 500 seats in state legislatures, erasing the hole the party found itself in after the infamous 2010 midterm “shellacking” that followed Obama’s first two years as president. The aftermath of that 2010 shellacking is instructive about what may be about to happen now. Back then, Republicans launched a concerted campaign to enact right-wing bills and gerrymander states where they held full control of state government. The party passed anti-union legislation in Michigan and Wisconsin, loosened gun laws in Kansas and Wyoming, and raised new hurdles to voting in Arizona, Texas, and elsewhere. It also drew GOP-friendly congressional and state-legislative maps in Pennsylvania, North Carolina, and other presidential battlegrounds, helping Republicans cling to a disproportionate share of seats even after many voters had started to prefer the alternative. Now the shoe is on the other foot. According to the States Project, a nonprofit that focuses on growing Democrats’ power in state legislatures, the party is on track to command more governing trifectas come January than Republicans did after 2010. Beyond erasing gerrymanders Republicans drew to advantage themselves, Democrats could attempt to lock in a durable edge for their own party for the foreseeable future. State legislatures are also responsible for the laws that touch many Americans’ lives most directly. And while some Democrats are wary of misreading the affordability-minded mandate voters delivered this year, the party’s big wins have the potential to unlock a productive few years of liberal legislating across the country. Bills to expand the availability of housing, block A.I. data centers, raise the minimum wage, expand Medicaid under the Affordable Care Act, fund public transit, protect abortion rights, promote clean power, and more are potentially on the table. “This will be a new era of policymaking that Americans can actually feel,” Mandara Meyers, who leads the States Project, said in a statement. Winning seats at the state level helps parties grow their bench of talent too. After all, the Democratic county councilors, state senators, attorneys general, and governors of today are the potential Democratic presidents of tomorrow. The Caveats This vision of our national future is just one of many possible outcomes. If the past 10 years have proved anything, it’s that change is one of the few political constants. And although it may feel as if Trump has frozen our politics in amber since 2016, there’s actually been plenty of churn beneath the surface. Latino and younger Americans swung toward the GOP in 2024, only to swing back to Democrats this year. Democrats have hemorrhaged working-class voters in Michigan, Ohio, and other Rust Belt states but offset those losses in Arizona, Georgia, and the rest of the Sun Belt. We’ve learned that demographics aren’t destiny for either party, and that could mean our politics will get more volatile, not less, as the Trump era comes to a close. And although the conditions are there for a decade of Democratic dominance, they aren’t self-executing. Democrats have shown an impressive ability to coordinate and compromise in the name of winning elections, but divisive leadership challenges, ideological infighting, and a bruising 2028 presidential primary could derail that cohesion. If Democrats fail to deliver solutions to the high cost of living, voters might decide to chuck them out as readily as they did Republicans this year. Nor are Democrats the only actors with agency: How Republicans choose to respond to 2026 could be just as consequential. So far, few have been brave enough to blame Trump for his role in this month’s historic losses. But the party will eventually emerge from under the president’s shadow, and when that happens, new political strategies could bloom. In fact, it’s possible to see green shoots already: In South Carolina, where Democrats captured a U.S. Senate seat for the first time since 1998, one longtime Republican aide characterized that defeat to the Wall Street Journal as “the ass-kicking we needed.” A party that’s actually scared of losing is also a party that will tread more cautiously. If the GOP interprets Democrats’ 2026 gains as a repudiation of Trumpism, it may think twice before calling elections rigged, targeting political opponents for retribution, tolerating corruption, or running a figure like Trump for the presidency again. Those uncertainties aside, the case that a more liberal United States could finally be heaving into view makes more sense the further you step back from the details. For centuries, America has resembled an undulating tapestry of victories followed by defeats, sea changes followed by retrenchments, setbacks followed by renewal. The catastrophe of the Civil War birthed Reconstruction. The Progressive Era responded to the excesses of the Gilded Age. The misery of the Great Depression sparked the New Deal. The tumult of the 1960s gave way to the Reagan Revolution. The Civil Rights Movement grew out of Jim Crow. Obama was succeeded by a man who had denied that the country’s first Black president was an American. So if a much bluer stretch of American politics does rise from the ashes of the Trump era, it would fit a historical pattern that’s been one long, angry decade in the making. Just remember: It won’t last forever. Congress Democrats Elections Electoral College House of Representatives Republicans Senate Supreme Court 2026 Midterms
Can Democrats Turn a Blue Wave Into a Blue Decade?
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Slate →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.