Box Office: Blumhouse Triumphs Over 2nd Straight Oscarbait Disappointment

Published Oct 11, 2026, 11:19 AM EDT Brennan Klein (he/him) is a senior news writer at Screen Rant, host of the Attack of the Queerwolf podcast, and contributor at Alternate Ending and Horror Press. He has been writing and podcasting about pop culture (especially horror movies) for over a decade at platforms including Blumhouse, Fangoria, Dread Central, The Backlot, and Arrow in the Head. Other Mommy and The Social Reckoning are repeating history at the domestic box office. 2026's Other Mommy, which is an adaptation of the Josh Malerman novel Incidents Around the House, is a Blumhouse-Atomic Monster production starring Jessica Chastain in a dual role as a loving mother and a creepy doppelgänger entity trying to take her place. It debuted in domestic theaters on October 9, the same day as The Social Reckoning, which is the sequel to the Oscar-winning 2010 hit The Social Network, following Mark Zuckerberg (Jeremy Strong) squaring off against Facebook whistleblower Frances Haugen (Mikey Madison). Original screenwriter Aaron Sorkin both writes and directs. The Ultimate · Horror Quote Challenge Name That Horror Movie “They’re coming to get you, Barbara.” ☠1960s 🔪1970s 👻1980s 💀1990s 🎭2000s ENTER IF YOU DARE → 01 Which horror movie features this iconic line?“I am your number one fan.” ASingle White Female (1992) BCape Fear (1991) CMisery (1990) DFatal Attraction (1987) ✓ Correct! Annie Wilkes’s obsessive declaration to author Paul Sheldon in Misery — Kathy Bates won the Oscar for this role. ✗ Not quite — it’s Misery (1990). Kathy Bates as Annie Wilkes delivers this line before things get very, very painful for her favorite author. NEXT → 02 Which horror movie features this iconic line?“We all go a little mad sometimes.” APeeping Tom (1960) BThe Birds (1963) CWhatever Happened to Baby Jane? (1962) DPsycho (1960) ✓ Correct! Norman Bates’s unsettling confession in Hitchcock’s Psycho — the film that invented the slasher. ✗ Not quite — it’s Psycho (1960). Norman Bates delivers this chilling line to Marion Crane before the shower scene changes cinema forever. NEXT → 03 Which horror movie features this iconic line?“Here’s Johnny!” AThe Amityville Horror (1979) BPoltergeist (1982) CThe Changeling (1980) DThe Shining (1980) ✓ Correct! Jack Nicholson’s terrifying ad-lib as he axes through the bathroom door in The Shining. ✗ Not quite — it’s The Shining (1980). Nicholson improvised this line while hacking through the door — Kubrick kept the cameras rolling. NEXT → 04 Which horror movie features this iconic line?“They’re all gonna laugh at you!” ACarrie (1976) BThe Exorcist (1973) CThe Omen (1976) DSuspiria (1977) ✓ Correct! Margaret White’s cruel warning to her daughter before prom night turns deadly in Carrie. ✗ Not quite — it’s Carrie (1976). Piper Laurie as Margaret White torments her telekinetic daughter with this prophetic warning. NEXT → 05 Which horror movie features this iconic line?“One, two, Freddy’s coming for you.” AFriday the 13th (1980) BChild’s Play (1988) CHellraiser (1987) DA Nightmare on Elm Street (1984) ✓ Correct! The eerie children’s jump-rope rhyme that haunts the dreams of Elm Street. ✗ Not quite — it’s A Nightmare on Elm Street (1984). The nursery rhyme warning of Freddy Krueger’s arrival. All five are iconic slashers, but only one invades your dreams. NEXT → 06 Which horror movie features this iconic line?“I want to play a game.” AHostel (2005) BSaw (2004) CThe Collector (2009) DCube (1997) ✓ Correct! Jigsaw’s signature greeting, delivered through his puppet Billy in Saw. ✗ Not quite — it’s Saw (2004). The Jigsaw Killer’s chilling invitation before his victims face impossible choices. NEXT → 07 Which horror movie features this iconic line?“It was the boogeyman.” ABlack Christmas (1974) BThe Texas Chain Saw Massacre (1974) CHalloween (1978) DWhen a Stranger Calls (1979) ✓ Correct! Laurie Strode’s terrified whisper to Dr. Loomis after surviving Michael Myers in Halloween. ✗ Not quite — it’s Halloween (1978). Laurie Strode whispers this to Dr. Loomis, who replies: “As a matter of fact, it was.” NEXT → 08 Which horror movie features this iconic line?“It rubs the lotion on its skin or else it gets the hose again.” ASe7en (1995) BAmerican Psycho (2000) CRed Dragon (2002) DThe Silence of the Lambs (1991) ✓ Correct! Buffalo Bill’s skin-crawling command to his captive in The Silence of the Lambs. ✗ Not quite — it’s The Silence of the Lambs (1991). Buffalo Bill delivers this disturbing line from his basement. All five films feature serial killers, but only one has this scene. REVEAL MY SCORE → The Body Count Your Survival Score 💀 / 8 Did you survive the horror quiz? ↻ SURVIVE AGAIN Per The Numbers, as of Sunday morning, Other Mommy is projected to earn a 3-day total of $27.5 million at the domestic box office by the end of its debut weekend, premiering at No. 1. Meanwhile, The Social Reckoning is turning out a disappointing $5.5 million (per Sony Pictures Entertainment), which should see it debut at No. 5. While it could still be on track to turn a small profit by the end of its run, this is less than a third of what The Social Network earned during its $22.4 million debut, not adjusted for inflation. This follows the exact pattern established during the first weekend of October, which saw the female-led genre adaptation Verity (which was based on the Colleen Hoover thriller novel of the same name and starred Dakota Johnson and Anne Hathaway opposite Josh Hartnett) take No. 1 over the big-budget Oscar play Digger, which starred Tom Cruise and was directed by four-time Oscar winner Alejandro G. Iñárritu. 2026's Digger hit No. 5 with an $8 million debut that puts it on track to lose more than $150 million and become one of the biggest bombs of all time. Below, see the full domestic Top 5 chart for this weekend (per Sony Pictures Entertainment, The Numbers, and Variety): # Title 3-Day Total Cumulative (Domestic) 1 Other Mommy $27.5 million $27.5 million (weekend 1) 2 Verity $11.4 million $53 million (weekend 2) 3 Resident Evil $8.3 million $138.5 million (weekend 4) 4 Heart of the Beast $7.1 million $49.7 million (weekend 3) 5 The Social Reckoning $5.5 million $5.5 million (weekend 1) The previous weekend's Top 3 titles are falling one spot apiece this weekend, slotting in neatly behind Other Mommy with Verity falling to No. 2 with a brutal sophomore drop of 64% (the worst for a Hoover adaptation, ahead of Reminders of Him's 55.5%), pushing Zach Cregger's Resident Evil to No. 3 in its fourth weekend and the Brad Pitt survival movie Heart of the Beast to No. 4 in its third. Both holdover titles are expected to post narrow drops of less than 40%. With two new titles debuting in the Top 5, a pair of other titles were ousted from the chart. Those would be Digger (which is expected to fall to No. 7 in its sophomore weekend behind DreamWorks' Forgotten Island, which had a lukewarm debut but has been posting solid week-on-week holds) and Robert Pattinson's To Catch a Predator movie Primetime (which is falling from No. 4 to No. 9 during its third weekend behind Digger and Christopher Nolan's The Odyssey, which is getting a boost because it returned to IMAX screens this weekend). Other Mommy and The Social Reckoning have so far continued a trend of genre releases that tie in better with the Halloween season triumphing over more awards season-oriented endeavors. Next weekend will test that trend, as - in addition to the arrival of the action movie Street Fighter - two genre releases (the Austin Abrams survival thriller Whalefall and the spider horror movie Crawlers) will be facing off against the new Jane Austen adaptation Sense and Sensibility. Enjoy ScreenRant's box office coverage? Click below to sign up for my weekly box office newsletter (make sure to check "Box Office" in your preferences) and get exclusive analysis, predictions, and more: Sign Up Release Date October 9, 2026 Runtime 93 Minutes Director Rob Savage Writers Josh Malerman, Nathan Elston Producers James Wan Cast Arabella Olivia Clark Bela Eight-year-old Bela forms a disturbing relationship with a sinister entity living inside her home, one that looks uncannily like her own mother. Main Genre Horror Executive Producer(s) Josh Malerman, Judson Scott, Macdara Kelleher, Michael Clear, Rob Savage, Ryan Lewis Release Date October 9, 2026 Runtime 112 Minutes Director Aaron Sorkin Writers Aaron Sorkin Producers Stuart M. Besser, Todd Black, Aaron Sorkin, Peter Rice Cast Mikey Madison Frances Haugen A recount of the true story behind The Facebook Files investigation, when a collaboration between Facebook engineer Frances Haugen and journalist Jeff Horwitz uncovered damning confidential company secrets about the ubiquitous social network. Main Genre Drama Executive Producer(s) Ellen Goldsmith-Vein, Broderick Johnson, Andrew A. Kosove, Lauren Lohman, Roger McNamee