Blake Breaks Silence on Hayley’s Assault Allegations After ‘The Ultimatum’ Cameras Stopped Rolling

Blake Robertson and Hayley Hendrich’s relationship deteriorated after Netflix’s The Ultimatum season 4, culminating in a physical altercation that led to Blake’s October 2025 arrest for assault in Texas.Blake denied allegations of physical violence, claiming he was defending himself when Hayley allegedly poured beer on him and escalated their argument during a heated confrontation at their home.Blake’s assault case was dismissed and expunged by prosecutors, though Hayley maintained her account of events and he revealed they continue to contact each other despite their turbulent split.Blake Robertson and Hayley Hendrich put their relationship to the test on season 4 of Netflix’s The Ultimatum, and though the couple found their way back to each other after their respective trial marriages, they faced some major issues way after the reality show’s cameras stopped rolling.Now, Blake is breaking his silence and denying Hayley’s allegations that he had gotten into a physical altercation with her after a heated argument, which reportedly happened before he was arrested in October 2025.“Placing hands on someone, that is something that I do not take lightly at all,” Blake told Page Six of the allegations.He confirmed that the “final straw” that led to their split a week before his arrest happened after Hayley “poured a beer” on him and he kicked her out of their Texas home. According to a booking summary obtained by the outlet, Blake was arrested for assault and booked with a Class C misdemeanor—which typically results in a $500 fine and no jail time—in Nacogdoches, Texas, on October 18.NetflixDuring a separate conversation with Reality Shrine, Blake shared his side of the story, alleging that Hayley “kept on escalating the conversation” and he “could not get the argument to stop.”“Come to find out she was recording me, and it felt like a set-up,” he explained. “But I was sitting there, and I just said, ‘Hey. We need to stop arguing, why are we still talking about this? Why is this going on? Why are we still arguing?’”Blake’s story comes after Hayley revealed their relationship took a turn when he got back from a golf trip with coworkers on the What’s the Reality? podcast.Add Cosmopolitan as a preferred source in your Google search results.Use your Google account to add this to your settings.“He comes back wasted. I start arguing with him, I’m like, dude, this is so disrespectful, I’m so angry at you,” she claimed on the pod’s July 22 episode, later alleging that he accused her of hitting him.Blake shared a different narrative during his chat with Page Six, in which he alleged that Hayley “stormed” toward him and that he attempted to de-escalate the situation by “swarming her hands,” walking her to her friend’s car, and sitting her in the backseat.“I said, ‘You guys take off,’” he shared. “I did not [hit her]. That was self-defense to get her away from me.”However, Hayley claimed that Blake ran off before the police arrived, and admitted that she showed the police the videos she recorded during the incident.After everything about the reported altercation and Blake’s arrest resurfaced after The Ultimatum season 4 reunion, he admitted that he and Hayley are “still in contact.”“Hayley and I still talk. We still talk on the phone, and everything is fine, so if this was such a horrible experience, why would she still be in contact with me?” he told Reality Shrine after explaining his piece.Per TMZ, Blake’s lawyer claims his case was “rightfully dismissed by the prosecutor almost immediately, and all records were expunged.”