Between confessing his sins in court and striking another deal with prosecutors: The dilemma facing Naasón Joaquín, leader of La Luz del Mundo in the US

Between confessing his sins in court and striking another deal with prosecutors: The dilemma facing Naasón Joaquín, leader of La Luz del Mundo in the US

The elusive Naasón Joaquín García, the top leader of the century-old Mexican church La Luz del Mundo, is running out of legal strategies and time before facing a trial starting in March in a federal court in Manhattan, New York. If it goes ahead, the trial would expose the secrets of the religious leader, his family, and his congregation, while federal prosecutors and their witnesses would seek to prove they operated a criminal organization involved in sexual trafficking and child exploitation practically since the sect’s founding.The only option that appears to remain on the table for the so-called Apostle of Jesus Christ to avoid trial is to sit down and negotiate with prosecutors in search of reduced charges and a lighter sentence. The religious leader faces six serious counts that could result in up to four life sentences. The decision is his to make, just weeks before the religious institution he heads marks a century of existence. On December 12, 1926, his grandfather, Aarón Joaquín González, arrived in Guadalajara, Mexico, with the message that God had chosen him as his representative on Earth and had entrusted him with founding what he considered the “true” Christian church.La Luz del Mundo’s most devoted followers rallied behind their Apostle to defend his innocence in New York, in a display of veneration that translated into a $2.7 million donation to cover the fees of the law firm handling his defense. García’s mother, Eva García de Joaquín, 80, and his nephew, Joram Núñez Joaquín, are also among the defendants. The elderly woman faces two life sentences and her grandson up to 20 years behind bars.There is precedent: in the criminal case that began in 2019 against the leader of La Luz del Mundo, a deal with the California Attorney General’s Office signed in June 2022 allowed him to avoid a sentence that would have kept him in prison for the rest of his life. He is currently serving nearly 17 years after admitting he sexually abused three teenagers who attended a temple in East Los Angeles. In 2025, the Apostle was transferred from a prison in Chino, California, to one in Brooklyn, New York, to face the new charges.Separately, the U.S. Department of Justice often favors plea deals — which can lead to lighter punishments for offenders — over taking cases to trial because of the time and resources they consume. Last Friday, a filing by the federal judge overseeing the new criminal case, Loretta Preska, seemed to push the Joaquíns in that direction.Setbacks in the New York courtPreska formalized and expanded in writing her decision to deny all motions recently filed by the Apostle, his mother, and his nephew in an attempt to avoid the trial scheduled for next year.In their filings, the Joaquíns argued that the sex trafficking charges should be dismissed because, their lawyers said, they rest on what they called “spiritual coercion.” In their view, that would force the jury to decide whether their religious beliefs are true or false. They refer specifically to the allegation that the crimes were committed by threats of “causing serious harm” of a spiritual nature. They maintain those charges violate the First Amendment to the United States Constitution, which protects religious freedom.Judge Preska rejected that argument, noting that the Department of Justice does not intend to question the congregation’s beliefs. “Indeed, the prosecution expressly states that it has no intention of proving that La Luz del Mundo’s doctrine is false, which renders the defendants’ concern that the jury must determine the truth of La Luz del Mundo’s religious precepts moot,” she wrote.In a separate motion, the Apostle’s nephew argued that a threat of exclusively spiritual harm cannot be considered “serious harm.” The magistrate did not accept that interpretation either. In her ruling, she held that the concept expressly includes “nonphysical” and “psychological” harms.García’s mother, meanwhile, sought to eliminate one of the most serious charges: the one related to the law against corrupt organizations influenced by organized criminal activity, known as the RICO Act. That legislation has been used by the Department of Justice to pursue members of criminal organizations ranging from Italian-American mafia families to drug cartels and violent street gangs.In her motion, Eva García requested that this charge be dismissed, struck, or limited, as she believes it is based on alleged criminal activities previously committed overseas that, in her interpretation, were not punishable at the time they occurred. She also requested that any retroactive application of extraterritorial jurisdiction be prohibited in cases involving human trafficking and forced labor.Preska also denied that request. The judge explained that, to be held liable for a conspiracy under the RICO Act, a defendant need not have personally committed or agreed to commit each of the predicate offenses underpinning the charge.“Because the indictment alleges the existence of an agreement to commit organized criminal acts, both domestically and after 2008 (without it being necessary that García de Joaquín personally committed them), the first count must be maintained at this stage of the proceedings,” the judge concluded.If the trial proceeds, in January federal prosecutors must provide the defense with a description of the specific organized criminal acts they attribute to the Apostle and his relatives. In March, both parties must file their respective witness lists and the evidence they plan to present to the jury.Sign up for our weekly newsletter to get more English-language news coverage from EL PAÍS USA Edition

Original Source

Read the full article at English →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.