Beijing ranked its guests in Shenzhen. Putin came second, and so does his bluff

Beijing ranked its guests in Shenzhen. Putin came second, and so does his bluff

Xi Jinping does not go to airports. Chinese protocol keeps the head of state off the tarmac, and when President Donald Trump visited Beijing in May, Xi didn’t meet him there. On Wednesday in Shenzhen, Xi stood at the foot of Air Force One’s stairs and hugged him, Axios reported. Vladimir Putin had landed a few hours earlier. He got Cai Qi, Xi’s chief of staff. A serious man, fifth in the party hierarchy — one of the highest. Still not Xi. Russian and Ukrainian social media spent the night comparing the two men’s heights, which tells you how the pictures came out.That evening, at the APEC leaders’ photo, footage showed Xi gesturing Putin to his spot. Xi’s wife, Peng Liyuan, stood between them, Kyiv’s NV reported. Trump stood at Xi’s other shoulder.In Chinese diplomacy, none of that is accidental. Chinese tradition doesn’t seat people by accident. China was ranking its guests. Putin came second. Hold that picture against the words. Putin told Russian state media he expected “considerable potential benefits” from Thursday’s three-way summit, CNN reported. A week earlier, Iran’s security chief, Mohsen Rezaei, fresh from a meeting with Putin in Moscow, swore Tehran would not remove “a single atom” of its enriched uranium, the Washington Times reported. Both regimes are selling the same line. We have time. You don’t.I wouldn’t buy it. Neither, apparently, does Xi.Negotiators call what really decides a deal BATNA, the best alternative to a negotiated agreement. In plain English, what happens to you if the talks collapse. Game theorists add a rule worth printing on every summit badge: Talk is cheap, so it proves nothing. The only question is what waiting actually costs.For Russia, a lot. Its Finance Ministry said on Nov. 10 that the deficit for January through October reached 5.23 trillion rubles, and it now expects 7.3 trillion for the year, almost double what the budget law allowed, bne IntelliNews reported. Five days earlier, the government quietly authorized another 1 trillion rubles of borrowing.Here is the part Moscow would rather you skip. This happened with oil at a windfall. Urals topped $100 a barrel in October, and Russia’s oil export earnings jumped about 65% from a year earlier to $21.2 billion, the IEA estimated. Putin is getting the best oil prices in years, courtesy of the Iran war, and still can’t pay for his own.Iran’s numbers are uglier. Inflation hit 76.8% in October, and the rial lost nearly 40% of its value in seven months, Iran International reported, citing official data. Oil output fell by nearly half from prewar levels in October, per IEA figures. What still gets out goes by truck or hides in Iraqi waters: around 250,000 barrels a day by Kpler’s count, maybe 500,000 by FGE’s. Kpler warns that, for the first time ever, Tehran’s crude revenue by mid-December could hit zero.And look at the travel schedule. Rezaei flew to Moscow on Nov. 5. In October, Putin passed Iran’s peace proposal along to Trump and offered, again, to take Iran’s uranium off everyone’s hands, an offer he also repeated at Valdai. For a regime that doesn’t need a deal, Tehran is working awfully hard to find a broker. For a Kremlin that doesn’t need Washington, Moscow keeps volunteering to fix Washington’s problems.People who are really winning a war of attrition rarely ask for peace. The ones losing it tend to hold press conferences about how little they need it.Fair objections exist. Cai Qi is a heavyweight, and this was Putin’s first APEC group photo in nine years, which the Kremlin is selling as a comeback. China is no friend of Ukraine, Israel, or America, and it is still Moscow’s economic lifeline. But that is my point. Beijing gave Putin a seat at the table, not a place at the head of it. A junior partner’s fallback depends on its patron’s mood, and Xi just showed whose company he prefers.Critics will also say Russia can keep fighting. They’re right: Moscow still has gold reserves and banks to lean on, and Ukrainian analysts estimate it can finance the war for roughly two more years. Iran’s rulers have outlasted sanctions for decades, and this outlet warned on Wednesday that delay lets Tehran rebuild missiles and drones. But a war of attrition doesn’t end when one side runs out. It ends when continuing looks worse than the deal on the table. That is why Washington should hold, not drift: Steady pressure, plus a credible threat of renewed strikes, is what makes 2027 look worse to Tehran and Moscow than a deal now.So what should Washington do?Stop paying for a deal its adversaries need more than it does. In Shenzhen, Trump should repeat what he told Putin in the spring: “Before you help me, I want to end your war.” That means no Russian custody of Iranian uranium, which would hand Moscow a seat at the Iran table and a free chip to trade on Ukraine. It means no more favors on Russian oil and diesel while Russian missiles still hit Ukrainian cities. And it means no sanctions relief or easing of the blockade for Tehran until its 60% stockpile leaves Iran under American or IAEA control, as Uriel Zehavi argued in these pages this month.TRUMP, XI, AND PUTIN WON’T SIGN A NUCLEAR TREATY. THEY CAN STILL PREVENT AN ACCIDENTAL WARNone of this costs American taxpayers a new dollar. The blockade is already running. The sanctions are already written. The only thing Washington has to spend is patience, and on the numbers, it has more of that than Moscow or Tehran. Played this way, the uranium can leave Iran without another round of bombing.Putin and Rezaei are telling the world they can wait forever. Their budgets say they can’t. Even their hosts in Shenzhen seem to know it.Leonid Baratz is an investigative journalist based in Jerusalem and a Middle East correspondent for Ukrainian national television and radio. He writes on diplomacy and security for Israel’s BeSheva media group. His analyses were published on the Atlantic Council’s UkraineAlert and Middle East Forum.

Original Source

Read the full article at Washingtonexaminer →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.