Autism expert condemns school over boy allegedly forced to empty clogged toilet bare-handed

Autism expert condemns school over boy allegedly forced to empty clogged toilet bare-handed

Correction: Autism NZ received over 3500 enquiries in the year to 30 June 2026 not 35,000 as the copy originally stated.Megan* said her son, who was on a waiting list for further formal autism and ADHD evaluation, was also made to wait with his nose against the wall for hours as "punishment" for clogging the toilet.Autism NZ spokesperson Kirsty Whalen-Stickley said what the mother said her son was subjected to was "completely unacceptable"."It constitutes abuse and is not helpful for any child, regardless of what needs they may have. To put a vulnerable child in that position is horrific. I haven't heard something quite that awful in a very long time."After the incident at Paengaroa School last Thursday, the boy's parents removed him and his older brother from the school.But she wanted a public apology and for the school's principal and the staff member involved to be stood down."If [the principal] had just been accountable and actually made [the staff member] apologise to my child, we would have left the school quietly and happily."It had been over one year since Megan was first told her son Elijah* presented with several features suggestive of autism spectrum disorder (ASD) and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). He was on a waiting list and had not received a formal diagnosis.She said that as a young parent, she felt unsupported advocating for her son.She left her most recent parent-teacher conference in tears, and she had not been to one since."I left crying because of the way they spoke about my son. I understood their concerns, but it was harsh. Not one positive thing was said about him."As a mother, it's heartbreaking to listen to someone speak about your child that way. If you met my son, he has the biggest heart. He will go out of his way to help anyone."Kiwi stand-downShe said this year, Paengaroa School provided Elijah with a teacher aide."She has been amazing, helping him to have more confidence and with socialising. She has made him more open to learning, and she's made him enjoy going to school. I cannot thank this woman enough. She has a beautiful soul. She has helped him in every aspect possible."But she said even with a diagnosis, Elijah would not qualify for government funding.That meant the aide was not with him in the classroom all the time, and Megan said she would often be asked to collect her son during the school day, when the aide was not there."At least every fortnight I'd have a phone call. They would tell me he's sick, he's tired, he needs to come home. I'd get him home, and there'd be nothing wrong with him, and he'd say, 'Mum, they just said I was being too much today, so they sent me to the office'."Whalen-Stickley said that situation was so common there was a name for it."The colloquial term that gets tossed around is a Kiwi stand-down, and it's the idea that the child hasn't been formally stood down or excluded from a class but is regularly being excluded because the parents are being asked to pick them up."Every child has the right to access education, and if that is happening on a regular basis, it should be escalated to the Ministry of Education because it is common practice, but it is not acceptable practice. It is illegal."Megan said she had offered to help pay for her son to have an aide and wished the school had communicated with her more about what was happening in the classroom.Whalen-Stickley said educators were generally trying their best.She said even schools with students with the highest, most severe learning and disability needs, who qualified for learning support under the Ongoing Resourcing Scheme, struggled."Teacher aide funding is very limited, and we hear regularly from teachers that they desperately need more support in the classroom."It's very difficult funding to get, and even students who do have teacher aide funding, often schools and teachers are having to make decisions to distribute that teacher aide time across the many kids who need support rather than being able to dedicate that time to the individual child who's actually funded to have the teacher aide because there's just so much need."More funding neededShe said a government-funded programme Autism NZ used to run, Tilting the Seesaw, allowed teachers, parents, and other school staff to make a plan for a child who needed extra support in school."They didn't have to have a diagnosis in order to access that programme, and it was incredibly positive and successful, but unfortunately the funding for that programme has been cut."We're looking at providing alternative programmes that are similar so that teachers are getting the resources, strategies, and support they need and not having to have a diagnosis, as a threshold for access is super important."Whalen-Stickley said wait times varied between regions, but it could take anywhere from just a few months to years to get an autism diagnosis."There's a huge demand for diagnosis, and the current services are generally not meeting that demand."Some people pursue a diagnosis privately, but the costs can be very high, into the thousands of dollars, so it's really not achievable for a lot of people and a lot of families."She said they had to stop adding people to the wait list for Autism NZ's own Wellington-based diagnosis clinic because they were too overwhelmed.She said Autism NZ received over 3500 enquiries in the year to 30 June 2026, relating to requests for support and information about getting a diagnosis."In New Zealand we have a bit of an ambulance at the bottom of the cliff approach to support. That is starting to change with more early intervention programmes like our Early-Years Support Pathway, which was funded by the Social Investment Agency, which is great, but it's very limited in one specific area."If we're constantly supporting children, adults, and families after they've experienced crisis, we're not putting the support in the right place, and we need to get the right support at the right time before someone reaches crisis point."She said more funding was needed to support children like Elijah."In this instance, it seems like what has happened is the lack of support is going to lead to further trauma and far more challenges for the student and the family, which is just really sad. "Health NZ acknowledges frustrationsIn a statement to RNZ, Health NZ national chief mental health and addiction Leeanne Fisher acknowledged Megan's and Autism NZ's frustrations."Demand for ADHD and autism assessment and support has increased substantially, and we recognise this is putting pressure on services and contributing to long waits in some areas. We are continuing to work on ways to improve access and make the best use of available resources, including strengthening referral pathways and working across primary, specialist, and community services."Addressing this increased demand requires sustained investment and a coordinated response across health, education, and community services, alongside work to make the best use of existing specialist capacity."She said families did not need to wait for a diagnosis before seeking support from their GP, school, or early childhood provider."Support can involve health, education, and community services, recognising that children referred for neurodevelopmental concerns often have a range of overlapping needs."Ministry investing in specialised supportMinistry of Education learning support deputy secretary Bridget White said it has been investing in specialist support, including increasing the number of hours teacher aides spend in schools."We acknowledge that families' experiences of accessing support can vary and are committed to improving the responsiveness and capacity of the learning support system."We are continuing to strengthen the learning support system to ensure children receive help as early as possible and that transitions from early learning to school are well supported. Budget 2025 included significant investment in learning support across the education system. This investment includes additional specialist roles, increased teacher aide hours being phased into schools, and further investment in specialist services to better support learners, schools and whānau. Many of these initiatives began from the start of the 2026 school year and will continue to be expanded over the coming years."From 2027, the Ministry will also fund professional learning and development for teacher aides and other support staff working with neurodiverse learners, focused on inclusive practice and strengthening learning environments that support ākonga participation, belonging and learning."On Kiwi stand-downs, White iterated that schools could not exclude students or send them home early on the basis of their disability."When the Ministry becomes aware of a barrier to enrolment or attendance, we work with students, their parents and whānau, and schools to return students to regular attendance as soon as possible. Through this work, the Ministry does not investigate whether the student has a disability specifically, but responds to the learning support needs of the student."She said if complaints were not resolved by the school, they could be made to the Ministry of Education and then the Ombudsman.But Megan said she was speaking out in the hope that no other child had the same experience as her son.Paengaroa School and the Ministry of Education both said they were investigating "concerns raised", but could not comment further while the investigation was ongoing.*RNZ has chosen not to name the individuals.

Original Source

Read the full article at Rnz →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.