An Alien Civilization Lived on Mars. But a Nuclear Disaster Wiped It Out, a Controversial Theory Claims.

7 min readHere’s what you’ll learn when you read this story:John Brandenburg—a plasma physicist at an aerospace development company— argues that there was an alien civilization on Mars, but it wiped itself out. He cites data from NASA’s Curiosity rover, claiming that xenon levels on the Red Planet indicate a nuclear disaster. However, many experts disagree with the theory and suggest that there are inconsistencies in the physicist’s reasoning. The aliens were next door, and somebody killed them. That’s the story plasma physicist John Brandenburg, PhD, tells about Mars. His theory suggests that a civilization built monuments on our neighboring planet before nuclear explosions wiped it out. He also argues that humanity must investigate—because we could face the same danger.In his 2014 Journal of Cosmology paper, Brandenburg presents Martian chemistry and supposed ruins as evidence of a planetary massacre. Both the journal’s editorial standards and Brandenburg’s theory itself have drawn criticism from other scientists. But the decisive question is whether his proposed explanation fits the measurements he provides. Dismissing the alleged attack leaves another question worth asking. If a civilization had flourished somewhere in our solar system and disappeared billions of years before we started looking, what would remain? Could we send a rover across its former home without ever knowing what had been there?Brandenburg—who did not respond to requests for an interview—argues that we’ve already found evidence of nuclear explosions in Mars’s atmosphere, focusing particularly on the Red Planet’s xenon measurements. Xenon comes in several forms, called isotopes, each with different numbers of neutrons in their atoms. Timothy Swindle, PhD—a professor emeritus and director emeritus at the University of Arizona’s Lunar and Planetary Laboratory—explains that radioactive decay and reactions caused by radiation can add to that mix. If an explosion produced the xenon on Mars, scientists would expect to find those isotopes in certain proportions.Some of the evidence Brandenburg referenced comes from pieces of Mars that landed here on Earth. NASA’s Curiosity, a car-sized rover that landed on Mars in August 2012, gave scientists a way to check these meteorite findings against the atmosphere of our celestial neighbor itself.The “spacecraft measurements by Curiosity match those in one class of Martian meteorites quite closely,” Swindle says, apart from small differences in isotopes Brandenburg doesn’t discuss. Older rocks, on the other hand, tell a somewhat different story. Allan Hills 84001, a Martian meteorite found in Antarctica in 1984, contains a slightly different xenon mix, Swindle says, “suggesting that the atmosphere may have changed over billions of years.” And when asked if the xenon measurements support Brandenburg’s explosion claim, Swindle disagrees. “In a word, no,” he says.Brandenburg focuses on the unusually high proportion of xenon-129 in Mars’s atmosphere. A nuclear explosion could produce it, but its presence alone hardly clinches the case. Swindle says the problem becomes clearer when you look at how Brandenburg tries to recreate the full Martian xenon pattern. In the 2014 paper, Brandenburg starts with the isotope mix found in Earth’s atmosphere, then calculates what would happen if xenon measured after nuclear tests were added to it. He adds just enough of the nuclear-test xenon to bring xenon-129 up to the level measured on Mars. That isotope is bound to match because Brandenburg used it to set the proportions.Several other isotopes also appear to line up. But Swindle points out that fission, the splitting of atomic nuclei that causes a nuclear explosion, doesn’t produce four of them. Their agreement says only that Mars’s starting xenon looks similar to Earth’s, not that an explosion occurred. The meaningful test is whether the mixture also matches the other isotopes that fission does produce. It doesn’t. The fit gets progressively worse among the heavier isotopes. At xenon-136, Swindle says Brandenburg’s plotted mixture contains 50 percent more than the amount measured on Mars. “Normally, if you can’t match it to within a few percent, it’s not a good match at all,” he says.Swindle also identifies an internal contradiction. Brandenburg invokes a shift toward lighter fission products to explain xenon-129. Swindle says that shift should produce progressively less xenon as you move from isotope 131 to 132, 134, and 136. But Brandenburg’s calculated mixture already predicts too much of those heavier isotopes compared to the amounts measured in Mars’s atmosphere, and the gap gets larger with each one. “The mismatch is in the opposite direction,” Swindle says.There’s another possible source of xenon-129. Radioactive iodine-129 decays into it naturally, although that explanation brings its own timing problem. Half of the iodine-129 decays every 15 million years, so most of it would have disappeared early in Mars’s history. The difficult part, Swindle says, is coming up with a timeline in which Mars released so much decay-produced xenon-129 after the planet had already lost most of its atmosphere.Here, it’s important to distinguish between Brandenburg’s 2014 and 2023 papers. In the more recent work, he uses different xenon comparisons. The paper was published by Scientific Research Publishing—an organization included on librarian Jeffrey Beall’s archived list of potentially predatory resources. Swindle’s criticism addresses the comparisons in the 2014 paper, not the newer analysis.Brandenburg also sees another clue supporting his explosion theory in the ratio of argon-40 to argon-26 on Mars, which is higher than it is on Earth. He argues that Mars must have received an unusual dose of argon-40. However, Swindle says that considering the actual amounts of these isotopes paints a different picture. Per gram of planet, Mars’s atmosphere has only about 2 percent as much argon-36 as Earth’s, and it also has less argon-40. In other words, the ratio is high because Mars has so little argon-36, not because it has an unexplained surplus of argon-40. All things considered, Swindle would not say an ancient explosion was impossible. He calls the isotopic evidence “very, very weak.”Outside scientists have other ideas about what may have happened to Mars’s xenon. In their 2024 Science Advances study, “Impact sculpting of the early martian atmosphere,” Oliver Shorttle and his colleagues used laser-driven shocks and computer models to study the effects of objects colliding with early Mars. They found that repeated collisions during the solar system’s first 200 to 300 million years of existence could’ve knocked xenon out of the planet’s atmosphere. The lighter xenon isotopes escaped more easily than the heavier ones, changing the balance of what remained. That could explain much of the pattern scientists measure today, although the study doesn’t explain the extra xenon-129 at the center of Brandenburg’s argument.What we do know is that Mars once had rivers and lakes, and researchers have found ways to explain how they dried out—without nuclear devastation. Measurements from NASA’s MAVEN spacecraft show how solar wind and radiation stripped away atmospheric gas on Mars. Some of the water went into the rocks and may still be there, bound up in minerals in the planet’s red crust. This put the estimated amount of water at 30 to 99 percent of the planet’s original conditions, according to a 2021 study published in Science. Having water makes Mars a place worth searching for life, but it doesn’t tell us if anything lived there.Any microbes living on Mars might’ve had somewhere to go as the surface dried out, perhaps underground, where conditions could have allowed them to survive. But Brandenburg is asking us to imagine inhabitants who built things, which is a much bigger leap. “We see zero evidence of ancient technological species in the Solar System,” says Jason Wright, PhD, a Pennsylvania State University astronomy and astrophysics professor and director of the school’s Extraterrestrial Intelligence Center.Wright points to Gavin Schmidt and Adam Frank’s 2018 Silurian Hypothesis paper, which asks how an earlier industrial civilization might register in Earth’s geological record. (Though it doesn’t make an argument that one existed.) Wright says we might have only a few million years before the evidence becomes too hard to recognize as something a civilization left behind. The paper also considers chemical signatures that might outlast recognizable artifacts.On Mars, Wright imagines a rover discovering an unmistakably technological device buried in sand. However, erosion complicates its survival. “Many artifacts that we, or our ancestors, considered to be durable may not persist for million-year timescales,” says Jacob Haqq-Misra, PhD, an astrobiologist and senior research investigator at Blue Marble Space, a nonprofit research institute based in Seattle.Haqq-Misra suggests machine learning could help search high-resolution Martian imagery for anomalies. Recognition would require investigation with experts in natural planetary processes. “We should investigate all anomalies, but we should not assume all anomalies are evidence of aliens,” he says. A strange feature could eventually reveal an ordinary explanation or something scientifically new. The investigation has value even when the anomaly turns out to have a natural cause.Brandenburg’s 2014 paper turns his alleged catastrophe into a warning about hostile civilizations. He proposes human exploration to help humanity avoid a similar fate. But Wright rejects the premise that cosmic silence necessarily requires an explanation: “The Fermi paradox isn’t really a problem that demands an answer.” Interstellar travel is difficult, and we have done limited searching.Likewise, the Great Filter—a proposed obstacle to life’s advancement—need not exist. Wright cautions that nuclear war would not necessarily eliminate all human life, much less establish a universal fate. “We regularly project our own existential fears onto hypothetical aliens,” he says.Haqq-Misra offers a possibility without a massacre: “Another civilization could have even visited the solar system long ago, with few if any traces left behind.” Civilizations might miss one another in space and time.Understanding what alien traces could look like is worthwhile. However, before we treat Mars as a warning, the isotope mix predicted by Brandenburg’s proposed explosion needs to match what we actually found there. As is the case with all of our search for extraterrestrial life thus far, the question still remains: Are we—and have we always been—truly alone in the cosmos?Special Digital IssuesAugust/September 2026Download HereThis issue is optimized for mobile/tablet viewing.It's also available on Apple News+.Featuring:➡ A Luxury Resort Hid a Secret Government Doomsday Bunker Below It for 35 Years. The Clues Were Everywhere.➡ 7 People Have Confessed to Being D.B. Cooper. Is One of Them Telling the Truth?➡ A B-52 Accidentally Lost Two Hydrogen Bombs Over North Carolina. One Nearly Detonated. One Is Still Buried.➡ The Secret Midnight Mission to Stop a 59-Story Skyscraper From Collapsing—and Save a New York City Neighborhood➡ Inside the Nightmare Scenario Where the Hoover Dam Goes Dark-and What Happens Next➡ The Deadly Steamboat Fire That Killed 1,000 People—and the Corporate Cover-Up That History ForgotJune/July 2026Download HereThis issue is optimized for mobile/tablet viewing.It's also available on Apple News+.Featuring:➡ 12 Years Ago, This Jumbo Jet Vanished Without a Trace. New High-Tech Ocean Robots May Finally Reveal What Happened.➡ No Rope. No Mistakes. No Second Chances. The Truth About Free Soloing—and the Climbers Who Never Came Back.➡ Nine Coal Miners Were Trapped Underground in a Surging Flood. "We're Going to Watch Them Die."➡ America Could Be Headed Toward a Future of Ghost TownsApril/May 2026Download HereThis issue is optimized for mobile/tablet viewing.It's also available on Apple News+.Featuring:➡ Blood Was Everywhere. Inside the Heroic Fight to Save a U.S. Nuclear Submarine After a Deadly Crash.➡ The FBI Denies Digging Up Long Lost Civil War Gold. Newly Released Records Suggest a Very Different Story.➡ The Hunt for a Deadly "Ghost Plane" Threatening the Nation's Capitol➡ This Simple Device Could Finally Defeat Alzheimer's and Safeguard Your MemoryFebruary / March 2026Download HereThis issue is optimized for mobile/tablet viewing.It's also available on Apple News+.Featuring:➡ Archaeologists Found a Skeleton Wearing a Silver Amulet. The Discovery Is Rewriting the History of Christianity.➡ The Stray Dogs of Chernobyl Are Rapidly Mutating. Scientists Are Still Trying to Figure Out What It Means.➡ New Evidence Could Upend What We Know About the Charles Lindbergh Baby Murder➡ Police Found Mysterious Notes in a Dead Man's Pocket. They Turned Out to Be Codes That Not Even the FBI Can Break.December 2025 / January 2026Download HereThis issue is optimized for mobile/tablet viewing.It's also available on Apple News+.Featuring:➡ An Angel of Death Preyed on Hospital Patients for Years.➡ How America's Most Advanced Lab Brought the Killer to Justice.➡ A 3,000-Ton Locomotive Was Loose, Unstoppable, and Filled With Toxic Cargo➡ An Underwater Cave Promised Adventure and Glory. No One Expected It to Become a Tomb.➡ Your Consciousness Can Predict the Future, Some Scientists SayOctober / November 2025Download HereThis issue is optimized for mobile/tablet viewing.It's also available on Apple News+.Featuring:➡ Inside the Secret Island Where Death Is Optional➡ A Legendary Ship Sank Without Warning. Fifty Years Later, Science Could Finally Solve the Mystery of the Edmund Fitzgerald.➡ This Tech Rebel Threw Away $900 Million in a Municipal Dump. Can Robots Find His Lost Fortune?➡ Sex Workers, LSD, and Mind Control: What Happened in the CIA's Lab of Nightmares at 225 Chestnut StreetAugust / September 2025Download HereThis issue is optimized for mobile/tablet viewing.It's also available on Apple News+.Featuring:➡ The Worst Air Disaster in American History Happened in Broad Daylight. Will More Mistakes Keep Happening?➡ NASA Has a Plan to Save Earth from Planet-Destroying Asteroids. It Sounds Even Wilder than Science Fiction. ➡ A Naval Officer Says Underwater UFOs Are Legitimate Threats. The Evidence Is Hard to Ignore.➡ When You Die, a Psychedelic Molecule Shapes Your Final Moments of Consciousness, a New Theory Reveals. Popular MechJune/July 2025Download HereThis issue is optimized for mobile/tablet viewing.It's also available on Apple News+.Featuring:➡ This Undersea Explorer Found America's Greatest Sunken Treasure. Then Things Got Really Weird.➡ Is Bigfoot Hiding in the Swamps of Florida? This Group Says It Has Proof.➡ Scientists May Have Gotten the Global-Warming Timeline Seriously Wrong.➡ A Third State Now Exists Between Life and Death, Some Scientists Now BelieveApril/May 2025Download HereThis issue is optimized for mobile/tablet viewing.It's also available on Apple News+.Featuring:➡ Scientists Successfully Revive a Dead Brain, Redefining the Boundary Between Life and Death➡ Fingerprints Keep Leading to Wrongful Convictions. Why Do Courts Still Rely on Them?➡ For 80 Years, the North Sea Held a Deadly Killer. Now Scientists Are Racing to Defuse the Threat.➡ They Built the Quietest Room in the World. Why Is Everyone So Afraid to Step Inside It?February/March 2025Download HereThis issue is optimized for mobile/tablet viewing.It's also available on Apple News+.Featuring:➡ This Guy Says He Knows the Truth About UFOs. Should We Believe Him?➡ Scientists Are Now One Step Away From Solving Nuclear Fusion—And Unlocking Unlimited Energy.➡ A Million-Dollar Heist Rocked the Art World— Then Amateur Sleuths Cracked the Case➡ A New Era of Missile Warfare Has Begun—and the U.S. Isn’t ReadyDecember/January 2025Download HereThis issue is optimized for mobile/tablet viewing. It's also available on Apple News+.Featuring:➡ A Clue Hidden in a 400-Year-Old Map Might Have Just Solved One of America's Greatest Mysteries➡ Inside the Deranged Plot to Smuggle Cocaine With an Armed Soviet-Era Submarine➡ This Brilliant Engineer Helped Build the B2 Bomber—Then He Sold America's Stealth Secrets to China➡ Your Consciousness Can Connect With the Whole UniverseOctober/November 2024Download Here This issue is optimized for mobile/tablet viewing. ➡ Untold Secrets Reveal How the Castle Bravo Test Became America’s Worst Nuclear Disaster➡ This Body Was Found Preserved on a Block of Ice in a Colorado Shed. It Had Been There for 30 Years. ➡ It Was Supposed to Be America's Greatest Victory in Space—Then It Became NASA’s Worst Nightmare➡ The Sidewinder Missile Ruled the Air—Then the Soviets Stole the DesignAugust/September 2024Download HereThis issue is optimized for mobile/tablet viewing.It's also available on Apple News+.Featuring:➡ This Man Knows the Truth About Amelia Earhart. Why Doesn't Anyone Believe Him?➡ The Army's Machine Gun Is No Match for Cheap Chinese Body Armor. So It's Making a New One.➡ Russia Built a Stunning Rival to the Supersonic Concorde—and Then It Fell From the Sky➡ A Navy Admiral Says Underwater UFOs Are a Threat—and the Pentagon is Withholding SecretsJune / July 2024Download HereThis issue is optimized for mobile/tablet viewing.It's also available on Apple News+.Featuring:➡ 4 Black Eggs Have Surfaced From the Depths of the Ocean— and the Mysterious Creatures Inside Are Baffling Science➡ A $2 Million Treasure Appeared in a Kentucky Cornfield. No One Knows Where It Came From.➡ A Million-Dollar Heist Rocked the Art World— Then Amateur Sleuths Cracked the Case➡ A New Era of Missile Warfare Has Begun—and the U.S. Isn’t ReadyApril May / 2024Download HereThis issue is optimized for mobile/tablet viewing.It's also available on Apple News+.Featuring:➡ The Man Who Knows Too Much About Area 51➡ How the FBI Took Down the Internet's Most Dangerous Website➡ A Staggering New Clue Emerges in the D.B. Cooper Hijacking Mystery➡ The Wildest Prison Break in U.S. History➡ The Secret to a Perfect Lawn Lies in One of These 10 Electric LawnmowersFebruary / March 2024Download HereThis issue is optimized for mobile/tablet viewing.It's also available on Apple News+.Featuring:➡ The Incredible Mystery of NASA’s Missing Moondust➡ Inside the Final Fiery Minutes of the East Palestine Train Wreck➡ Scientists Believe They’ve Unlocked Consciousness—and It Connects to the Entire Universe➡ Why This Unstoppable Stealth Bomber Will Rule the Skies➡ America Is Developing a New Nuclear Bomb—But Can’t Test Whether It Works➡ The 8 Best, Expert-Recommended Solar-Powered Generators Special Issue: NukesDownload HereThis issue is optimized for mobile/tablet viewing.It's also available on Apple News+.Featuring:➡ How Deadly Nuclear Waste Is Menacing This St. Louis Neighborhood➡ The Terrifying History of Russia's Nuclear Submarine Graveyard➡ Strange Mutations in Stray Dogs Near Chernobyl Suggest They Are Rapidly Evolving➡ America Dumped 56 Million Gallons of Radioactive Material Along the Columbia River—Then It Started to LeakDecember 2023 / January 2024Download HereThis issue is optimized for mobile/tablet viewing.It's also available on Apple News+.Featuring:➡ A New Clue In Amelia Earhart's Disappearance Emerges From the Ocean➡ How an Alleged Water Bandit Stole $25 Million in Water from Thirsty California Farms➡ A Coal Mine Exploded and 300 Miners Died. What Went Wrong?➡ China Just Built a Terrifying New Aircraft Carrier and May Soon Dominate the SeasOctober / November 2023Download HereThis issue is optimized for mobile/tablet viewing.It's also available on Apple News+.Featuring:➡ How Rats Took Over Our Cities—And Why We Can't Stop Them➡ This Language Is on the Verge of Extinction. Can It Be Saved?➡ America's Deadliest Warplane Returns in a New Doomsday Role➡ This Amateur Diving Group Kept Solving Cold Cases. Then Its Own Skeletons Surfaced. ➡ The Scientific Breakthrough That Could Put an End to Gray Hair. August/September 2023Download HereThis issue is optimized for mobile/tablet viewing.It's also available on Apple News+.Featuring:➡ Immortality Is in Reach. But It’s Not What We Imagined.➡ Your Next iPhone (and Nuclear Subs) Will Be Powered By Space Metal➡ Scientists Now Think We Can Build a Warp Drive➡ China and Russia Have Cracked the Stealth Code. Can the U.S. Regain Air Dominance?June/July 2023Download HereThis issue is optimized for mobile/tablet viewing.It's also available on Apple News+.Featuring:➡ The CIA’s Secret Plan to Build a Laser Beam Powered by the Human Mind➡ The 747 Ruled the Skies—Then One Slammed Into a Mountain➡ The Race to Contain AI Before Singularity➡ These Florida Homes Aren’t Just Hurricane-Proof—They’re Blueprints for the FutureApril/May 2023Download HereThis issue is optimized for mobile/tablet viewing.It's also available on Apple News+.Featuring:➡ AI Is on the Cusp of Taking Control—This Is How It May All Go Wrong➡ There’s No Weapon Russia Fears More Than the HIMARS Rocket Launcher➡ The Nuclear-Submarine Arms Race Is Getting Intense, and the U.S. Just Took a Massive Leap Forward➡ Iran Is Becoming a Drone Superpower—By Stealing American TechnologyFebruary/March 2023Download HereThis issue is optimized for mobile/tablet viewing.It's also available on Apple News+.Featuring:➡ The Greatest Treasure Hunt in American History Ended—and Then Things Got Weird➡ These Are the High-Powered Weapons Ukraine Needs to Send Russia Running➡ The Secret War to Take Out Iran’s Fleet of F-14 Jets➡ Russia Is Trying to Intimidate the U.S. with Hypersonic Missiles and Big, Scary Nukes—And It's More Than a ThreatDecember 2022/January 2023Download HereThis issue is optimized for mobile/tablet viewing.It's also available on Apple News+.Featuring:➡ Is Death Real? ➡ China and Russia Are Dominating the Hypersonic Arms Race—And It’s Not Even Close➡ When the South Fork Dam Broke, a Pennsylvania City Washed Away. Which Town Is Next?➡ The Navy’s New $13 Billion Aircraft Carrier Is Already Obsolete. This Weapon Can Save It.October/November 2022Download HereThis issue is optimized for mobile/tablet viewing.It's also available on Apple News+.Featuring:➡ Can America's M1 Abrams Still Compete With China's and Russia's Latest Battle Tanks?➡ Inside the Final Minutes of the Concorde Disaster—and How It Doomed Supersonic Travel for Decades➡ How the Massive Cargo Ship Felicity Ace Sank, Taking $400 Million Worth of Exotic Supercars With It➡ I Turned My Old Gas-Guzzler Into a Zippy EV for $15,000August/September 2022Download HereThis issue is optimized for mobile/tablet viewing.It's also available on Apple News+.Featuring: ➡ Cosmic Secrets of the 17 Most Powerful Mega-Telescopes on Earth—and Beyond➡ Can the Air Force's Secret, Hypersonic Jet Reclaim the Skies From Russia and China?➡ For 50 Years, the Zodiac Killer's 340 Cipher Stumped the FBI—Then Three Amateurs Cracked the Code➡ America's Most Fearsome Howitzer Has Entered the War in UkraineJune/July 2022DOWNLOAD HEREThis issue is optimized for mobile/tablet viewing.It's also available on Apple News+.Featuring:➡ Every Single Drone Fighting in the Skies Over Ukraine➡ How to Buy a New Car in 2022 Without Getting Fleeced➡ This Megastructure Could Keep Us Alive Forever➡ The Race to Revolutionize EV BatteriesEric Spitznagel is a frequent contributor to magazines like Playboy, Esquire, and the New York Times, and was employed for over two decades by the Second City comedy theater, where Stephen Colbert was his Secret Santa _twice.