All the benefits changes coming in the Milburn review – and their impact

All the benefits changes coming in the Milburn review – and their impact

Labour grandee Alan Milburn is ready to set out a radical overhaul of the UK’s welfare system in a bid to get more young people into work. Milburn will publish his final report into “Neets” – the under 25s not in education, employment or training – on Tuesday after a year-long review. He is widely expected to recommend that those aged 16 to 24 should no longer be allowed to claim the health element of universal credit (UC) or personal independence payments (PIP). The former Labour health secretary will also recommend that benefit money is reinvested in stronger employment support, including job subsidies and one-to-one advisers. His report is expected to be supported by Andy Burnham – but any cuts to young disabled people’s benefits will likely prove controversial with charities and left-wing Labour MPs. Universal Credit changes Under-25s would no longer be able to claim the health element of universal credit, according to reports on Milburn’s plans. At the moment, the basic rate of universal credit for under 25s is £338.58 a month. Those with a severe health condition or disability get an extra £429.80 in the health element – though it was halved to £217.26 for new claimants earlier this year. Under Milburn’s plans, under 25s would no longer be eligible for the health element and instead move on to a “youth allowance”, set at the same amount as the basic rate of universal credit. Those with the most profound disabilities, who are unable to work, would still qualify for a new benefit. It will be paid at a higher rate than current disability benefit, according to reports. But young people with depression, low or moderate anxiety, autism or ADHD would be expected to look for work, Milburn suggested, telling The Times it will be “much more targeted” on a “small cohort”. The impact: Milburn wants fewer young people getting higher rates of universal credit. But it is not clear how exactly the Government will decide which young people are deemed to have severe disabilities and are unfit to work. PIP changes Young people would no longer be able to claim PIP either, under Milburn’s plans. This is the benefit – worth up to around £780 a month – that currently covers the extra costs of living with a disability. Milburn is expected to recommend that under 25s are moved on to something called the “additional cost allowance” to help meet the cost of living with their condition. As with PIP, it would not be linked to work or be means tested. However, fewer people are likely to meet the criteria for the new allowance than the 453,000 under-25s who currently claim PIP, according to reports. Protesters fought against planned PIP cuts in 2025 – forcing Labour to revise its approach (Photo: Lab Ky Mo/Getty) Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden appeared to confirm on Sunday that he was on board with at least some of Milburn’s benefit recommendations. But it is not yet clear whether the Cabinet minister wants to cut universal credit or PIP, or both. “There will be people in the future who will not get what they would get today,” McFadden told BBC’s Sunday With Laura Kuenssberg. However, McFadden still has to hear PIP reform proposals by disability minister Stephen Timms later this month. Timms has been leading a review of the benefit. The impact: Milburn wants fewer young people claiming PIP or his planned equivalent. But it is not clear whether the Government will act on his PIP plan, with the Timms Review set to shortly make its own proposals. Costs and savings from benefit changes The extra investment in employment support that Milburn wants to see could cost £6bn, according to reports. The adviser has not yet put an overall cost to his plans, but he told the BBC on Sunday that it would “run into billions over a 10-year period”. Milburn argued that you would the start to see the benefits bill coming down and more young people paying taxes – but he has not given a particular sum that he thinks can be saved. “This is a 10-year plan,” he told Kuenssberg. “Everybody thinks, wave the magic wand, snap your fingers and you can do it in two or three years. I’m telling you, you can’t.” The number of Neets has risen to just under one million, a 3 per cent increase on last year, according to official figures for April to June. The i Paper understands that the Milburn Review estimates that 500,000 more under 25s will be in education, employment or training by 2036-37 as a result of the reforms – halving the number of Neets at the current rate. The Government currently spends around £25 on benefits for every £1 spent on work support, according to Milburn. He is expected to recommend that ratio is cut to two to one. The impact: The Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) has previously warned that boosting work support will not lead to benefit savings for 10 years, and will be expensive in the short term – something Milburn appears to accept. Will Burnham push through Milburn plans? The Prime Minister has strongly suggested he will act on Milburn’s review, promising a “root and branch rethink” of the system to tackle youth unemployment. But several left-wing Labour MPs have indicated they are prepared to oppose any benefit cuts, as they did under Sir Keir Starmer. The Starmer Government had to abandon planned cuts to PIP eligibility in summer 2025 after a major backbench rebellion. Labour MP Bell Ribeiro-Addy said she did not believe “you get a disabled young person into work by taking away the money that helps them to get into work”. However, Dame Meg Hillier, a leading Labour rebel against proposals under Starmer, has defended Milburn’s approach. The MP argued the plans appeared “very different to what was happening a year and a half ago”. More than 40 charities have warned against benefit cuts affecting disabled young people. The Joseph Rowntree Foundation has said young, disabled people “shouldn’t have to trade financial security for better employment support”, arguing that they “need both”. The impact: Any rebellion by Labour MPs will depend on how harshly the Government decides to restrict criteria for universal credit and PIP. It appears Labour MPs will have to vote on benefit changes with some uncertainty over the potential cost and savings.

Original Source

Read the full article at Inews →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.