This historic, foodie neighborhood continues to wow first-time tourists and hard-to-impress locals alike.Pasquale JonesContrary to other tourist-focused neighborhoods in New York (looking at you, Times Square), Little Italy boasts an innate charm that resonates with visitors and locals alike. Sandwiched between SoHo and the Lower East Side, this jewel box area is home to long-standing, family-owned restaurants and authentic Italian bakeries, the majority of which have been neighborhood staples for decades. Yet despite its touristy atmosphere, a unique feeling of old school New York magic hangs in the air; beyond the personality-less stands and souvenir shops, framed family photos on restaurant walls and structural imperfections of tenement buildings speak to a bygone area of the city’s past, evoking a sense of nostalgia that so many neighborhoods lack. Pop down to Mulberry Street and see for yourself—though be sure you know which spots are actually legit (that’s where we come in).A note on how we’re defining the area: Over the years, Little Italy’s boundaries have shrunk to focus on the touristic area of Mulberry Street and its immediate surroundings. While the southern and western boundaries of Canal Street and Lafayette Streets remain unchanged, the historic easterly Bowery boundary has arguably shifted to Elizabeth Street; similarly, the northerly boundary of Kenmare has also condensed down, according to many, to Broome Street. For the sake of this piece, we’re using the boundaries of Lafayette Street, Canal Street, Elizabeth Street, and Broome Street as a happy medium.Umberto’s Clam HouseUmberto’s Clam HouseLocated in the heart of Little Italy, Umberto’s Clam House is best known for its—you guessed it, all things clams. The restaurant quickly garnered attention shortly after opening in 1972, when mobster Joe "Crazy Joe" Gallo was shot in the restaurant’s dining room. Like its mafia-related history, the food at Umberto’s is as Italian-American as it gets. Baked clams and fried calamari are the appetizer list’s biggest show-stoppers, while superbly chilled clams on the half-shell pair exquisitely with equally cold (and generously sized) cocktails from the bar. Seafood-focused mains are the name of the game here, including the garlicky linguini and clam sauce and recently resurfaced scungilli with pasta served with piping hot red sauce.Address: 132 Mulberry Street, New York, NY 10013Il CortileIl CortileFor Italian-American eats in a less stereotypically Little Italy ambiance, Il Cortile is the way to go. Contrary to the old school Italian vibes found in the majority of the neighborhood’s restaurants, Il Cortile’s atrium-style glass ceiling and plant-filled room feel more like dining al fresco in Trastevere than the heart of Mulberry Street. The family-owned restaurant’s neighborhood roots date back to 1975, with a solid focus on Northern Italian cuisine. The homemade cheese ravioli and wood-fired pizzas are always a safe bet, though for meat lovers, springing for the Fettuccine di Parma made with sweet sausage and wild mushrooms won’t disappoint—and be sure to save room for the pillowy soft tiramisu made with creamy mascarpone and imported Italian ladyfingers drenched in espresso.Address: 125 Mulberry St, New York, NY 10013Original VincentsOriginal Vincent’sOriginal Vincent’s, often called The Original Vincent’s Clam Bar, is home to one of the richest restaurant success stories in Little Italy. Founded in 1904 by Giuseppe and Carmela Siano, the business began as a sidewalk street cart serving up fresh seafood and jars of homemade red sauce, available in mild, medium, and hot. Today, the restaurant sits on the corner of Mott and Hester Streets, and is still known for its signature gravies, baked clams, and linguini-based pasta dishes (don’t skip the frutti di mare). As in its earliest days, Original Vincent’s still sells jars of their red sauce to-go, making replicating the restaurant’s pasta dishes at home a breeze—simply grab a bottle of Chianti, cue up your Louis Primo playlist and voila.Address: 119 Mott St, New York, NY 10013PaesanoPaesanoPaesano of Mulberry Street is home to one of the coziest interiors in Little Italy, offering a peaceful refuge from the neighborhood bustle. Rustic twig bunches and leafy plants strung with twinkle lights hang from the ceiling, while traditional Italian frescos and framed family photographs adorn the whitewashed brick walls. Originally opened in 1961, the restaurant remains owned by the same family and continues to be known for their Southern Italian recipes, including linguini with clam sauce, wood-fired pizzas, and savory chicken marsala drenched in sautéed mushrooms. Meat lovers, don’t skip the restaurant’s signature Veal A La Paesano, featuring a juicy and tender veal base layered with thin slices of prosciutto, steamed broccoli, and gooey mozzarella cheese finished with succulent brown gravy.Address: 136 Mulberry St, New York, NY 10013chicken parm Lombardi’sLombardi’sFor serious pizza lovers, a trip to Lombardi’s is a no-brainer. Tucked on the corner of Mott and Spring, this neighborhood institution is credited as America’s first pizzeria, originally founded by Gennaro Lombardi in 1905. Lombardi quickly rose to fame for his large, heavily-topped pies, which he baked in an on-site, coal-and-gas oven. The result? Smoky crusts topped with perfectly balanced tomato sauce and gobs of whole milk mozzarella—along with sweet Italian sausage and various other accoutrements. The interior oozes with classic New York charm, featuring tables clad in red-and-white checkered cloths and framed family photographs strung along the red-hued walls. Head’s up, the spot is cash only, and while there’s an ATM on site, we recommend coming prepared to avoid the withdrawal fee.Address: 30 Spring St, New York, NY 10012Pasquale Jones-12_2. Brussels Sprout Pizza with Red Onion, Smoked Mozzarella & Lemon Pasquale JonesPasquale JonesIn a sea of mediocre neighborhood wine lists, Pasqule Jones offers a breath of fresh air for Little Italy exploring wine lovers. Situated on the cusp of the neighborhood’s boundaries (and easily identifiable by its rainbow neon lights), this Italian-American pizzeria first opened its doors in 2016 and quickly became a staple for industry folks and visiting oenophiles alike. Beloved for its wood-fired New York style pizzas (don’t miss the signature clam pie) and thick, homemade pastas, the restaurant’s warm-yet-casual ambiance is ideal for posting up with a pie and a bottle—especially if you’re after great Burgundy, Champagne, or Italian reds. Expect classic picks from Pierre-Yves Colin-Morey, Domaine de l’Arlot, and Vietti, as well ample fun and fresh selections from Sandlands, Chacra, and Domaine Gramenon.Address: 187 Mulberry St, New York, NY 10012LobsterTail Ferrara BakeryHolyCannoli Ferrara BakeryFerrara BakeryFinding sweet treats in Little Italy is no difficult feat, though few spots boast the history and authentic quality of Ferrara Bakery. Owned by the same family since 1892, this iconic pasticceria and espresso bar is best known for its hand-crafted cannoli and crispy-meets-creamy lobster tails, along with classic cookies (pignoli, rainbow), Italian-style cheesecake, and strong, espresso-based beverages—served with or without booze, dealer’s choice. Beyond the baked goods, Ferrara is beloved for its ornate, Victorian-style interior, featuring dark wood moldings and mirrored walls. Come for the ambiance, take the cannoli (or something like that).Address: 195 Grand St, New York, NY 10013dessert case Caffé PalermoCaffé PalermoAlthough less famous than nearby Ferrara, Caffé Palermo features the innate Italian charm one looks for when wandering the neighborhood. Owned and operated by Baby John DeLutro (the self-proclaimed “Cannoli King”) since 1973, the establishment lives up to its owner’s moniker, offering flavored iterations—including pistachio and hazelnut made with sweet ricotta cream, the former of which is one of the joint’s standouts—in perfectly crisp shells. What Palermo does have over Ferrara is a solid amount of outdoor seating, ideal for posting up with a cappuccino and people watching on Mulberry.Address: 148 Mulberry St, New York, NY 10013La Compagnie des Vins Surnaturels Lizzy RollinsLa Compagnie des Vins SurnaturelsIf you’re looking for a wine break between pizza and pastries, this is just the ticket. Located on Little Italy's western limits (Centre Street between Broome and Grand), this French-inspired wine bar offers extensive by-the-glass options and shareable bites, including cheese and charcuterie boards to larger main courses, including beef tartare and lemon spaghetti. The comprehensive wine list, which features anywhere from 750 to 1,000+ references at all times, leans unsurprisingly French, though ample selections from Italy, Spain, and the USA are also available. Our suggestion? Post up with a bottle of Grower Champagne and relish in the perfectly executed Parisian bar à vin ambiance.Address: 249 Centre St, New York, NY 10013Toby’s EstateToby’s EstateSituated on the neighborhood’s extreme western and southern boundaries (Lafayette Street and Broome Street), Toby’s Estate is a solid place for grabbing a coffee to-go before strolling Little Italy’s streets. Originally founded in Sydney, Australia by Toby Smith in 1997, the brand quickly expanded internationally and continues to rank amongst top global coffee shops, thanks to its single-origin pours and original house blends. The spot equally excels at espresso-based drinks, including lattés, cappuccinos, and unsurprisingly, flat whites. While the pastries at Toby’s are certainly good, we’d recommend saving your stomach space for Italian cookies and cannoli and nearby pasticcerie, including Caffé Palermo and Ferrara Bakery—more on those below.Address: 409 Broome St, New York, NY 10013Plato_Carne La EsquinaLa EsquinaTechnically located on the cusp of Little Italy’s historic boundaries (Kenmare and Broome Streets), La Esquina offers a flavor-packed reprieve from the classic red-sauce joints synonymous with the neighborhood. Situated in a former counter deli, this multi-level Mexican hotspot is best known for its casual taqueria (located in ‘The Corner Deli’ space) serving tacos, tortas, and ceviche. However, for those looking for something a bit stronger, head through the secret door and down the stairs to find the restaurant’s underground speakeasy. Lit by candle and adorned with Lucha Libre posters, the bar’s high-energy ambiance is prime for enjoying queso fundido and smoky Mexican street corn (elotes callejeros) washed down with expertly crafted agave-based cocktails.Address: 114 Kenmare St, New York, NY 10012Vicki Denig is a wine, spirits, and travel journalist based between New York and Paris. Her work regularly appears in Food & Wine, Wine-Searcher, Condé Nast Traveler, Forbes, and others. In addition to freelance journalism, Vicki is also a content creator and social media manager for a list of prestigious ... Read MoreRecommended Take in the best views, walk to the best museums, and indulge in a sexy, retro-futuristic NYC stay.Read full reviewA seriously stylish SoHo stay, where a prime Thompson Street address, bold interiors, and downtown glamour meet the warmth and intimacy of staying with your most fabulous friend.Read full reviewView All New York All of our best hotel, restaurant, and activity recommendations in one place.
A Guide to NYC’s Little Italy—and the Culinary Gems Hidden Among the Tourist Traps
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Cntraveler →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.