95-year-old widow loses appeal in 10-year fence row, faces over £1m in costs

95-year-old widow loses appeal in 10-year fence row, faces over £1m in costs

A 95-year-old British widow is facing legal bills of more than £1 million after spending a decade fighting her neighbours over a garden fence. The High Court has rejected an appeal by Margaret Kinnear against a ruling that she must pay her own legal costs in the dispute. This is despite her having successfully won a trespass claim against the couple living next door. The dispute involved a boundary line in the wealthy village of Sissinghurst, near Tunbridge Wells in Kent. At the centre of the case was a narrow strip of land measuring around 45 square metres. A judge described the area as being of "extremely limited, if any, usable or other value."A costly decade-long legal feudNeighbours Neil and Fiona Morgan put up a new fence in late 2015, replacing an existing fence along the boundary of Mrs Kinnear's property. According to court reports, the Morgans first placed fence posts on Mrs Kinnear's land without asking her. They later removed the posts and put up a second fence. This was followed by a temporary fence that extended further onto her property. Finally, they installed a permanent fence with concrete posts in January 2016. This became known as the "third fence." The legal battle began when the Morgans sued Mrs Kinnear for damages, claiming she had destroyed their second fence. Mrs Kinnear filed a counterclaim, accusing the couple of trespassing by putting up the fences. She also asked the court to declare that the true boundary ran along a line of hedges and trees.The case went to trial at Maidstone County Court in 2021. Recorder John Dagnall dismissed the Morgans' claim and ruled that they had trespassed by building the fences. He awarded Mrs Kinnear nominal damages of £2,600. However, the judge also rejected her request to have the third fence removed. Instead, he declared that the fence would mark the new boundary and awarded her £3,250 in damages instead of ordering its removal through an injunction.Judge describes result as a 'score draw'At a later hearing about legal costs in 2024, Recorder Dagnall ruled that both sides should pay their own legal bills. He effectively described the outcome as a "score draw." This left Mrs Kinnear responsible for her entire legal bill, which was reported to exceed £1 million. The Morgans had also faced substantial legal expenses. However, they represented themselves for much of the court battle, meaning their overall costs were lower. Mrs Kinnear appealed against the decision on legal costs, arguing that she had been the real winner of the case. Her lawyers said Neil Morgan's "egregious" and "disgraceful" behaviour during the proceedings should have led the court to order the Morgans to pay her legal expenses.High Court appeal dismissedThe appeal was heard in the High Court last week by Mr Justice Tappin. Mrs Kinnear's barrister presented examples of personal insults used by Mr Morgan in court documents and communications. These included attacks on opposing lawyers, their staff and judges. In one email, he reportedly called a junior solicitor a "lying hypocritical devious arse." In a letter sent to the court, he described a Deputy District Judge as "moronic and genuinely not fit to judge vegetables at a village fete."Delivering his judgment yesterday, Mr Justice Tappin agreed that Mr Morgan's language was "deplorable and unacceptable." However, he found no reason to overturn the original judge's decision. He agreed that Recorder Dagnall had been entitled to conclude that Mr Morgan's behaviour did not justify changing the order on legal costs. The High Court judge also supported the original decision to consider Mrs Kinnear's failure to win her main argument about the location of the property boundary. Although she had won her trespass claim, she had not secured the outcome she wanted on the boundary itself.Mr Justice Tappin also expressed regret about the huge amount of time and money spent on the dispute. Reporting on the judgment, The Independent quoted Mr Justice Tappin as saying that the argument over the "sliver of grass, tree and scrub... of extremely limited, if any, usable or other value" had led to an "expenditure of time, cost and energy wholly out of proportion to the financial value of the area of land in dispute." The High Court's decision means that the 95-year-old widow must pay her own legal costs, which exceed £1 million, bringing another setback in her decade-long dispute with her neighbours.

Original Source

Read the full article at Timesofindia →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.