9 Years Ago, Jon Bernthal Teamed With Taylor Sheridan to Deliver His Most Devastating Performance

9 Years Ago, Jon Bernthal Teamed With Taylor Sheridan to Deliver His Most Devastating Performance

Image via Dave Starbuck/Future Image/Cover Images Published Nov 21, 2026, 7:53 AM EST Rotten Tomatoes | Letterboxd | Metacritic Carolyn Jenkins is a voracious consumer of film and television. She graduated from Long Island University with an MFA in Screenwriting and Producing where she learned the art of character, plot, and structure. The best teacher is absorbing media and she spends her time reading about different worlds from teen angst to the universe of Stephen King. Sign in to your Collider account Jon Bernthal is known for his gun-toting, intense characters, but one of his best depictions of masculinity was only for a few scenes of screen time in Taylor Sheridan’s masterpiece, Wind River. After writing Sicario and Hell or High Water, Sheridan directed his own feature film that takes on yet another strictly American issue. The neo-Western takes place on the titular Indian Reservation, following the sudden death of a young Indigenous woman, Natalie (Kelsey Asbille). Statistics about crimes against this demographic do not exist, which is the stark point Wind River makes. ​ As local hunter Cory Lambert (Jeremy Renner) and FBI Agent Jane Banner (Elizabeth Olsen) set out to solve the murder, they explore the systemic oppression against Indigenous people, particularly the female demographic. Natalie is just one of many women on Reservations who are harmed and ignored in America. Bernthal also joins the cast in a surprise role that hammers home this idea in one of his most devastating performances. ​ Jon Bernthal Represents What Humanity Is Capable of in ‘Wind River’ ​ Wind River is a scathing view of the plight of Indian Reservations and how the community is treated by the government. Cory is particularly motivated by Natalie’s death because she was best friends with his daughter, Emily, who also died under similar circumstances. Even as Jane gets involved in the investigation, she is railroaded by the law, causing even more frustration about how a community is so neglected by the country they live in. ​ Cory and Jane take it upon themselves to go rogue and follow the clues that at first seem to lead to Natalie’s white, older boyfriend. They discover she was dating Matt Rayburn (Jon Bernthal), a security agent at a local oil drilling site, and suspect him of killing her. The truth is much more harrowing when they also find Matt’s body dumped in the cold. ​ Bernthal appears briefly in a heartbreaking flashback that drives the central thesis of Wind River home. Natalie and Matt genuinely love each other, a fact that is palpable in the scene. Natalie visits him at his trailer, but their quiet moment of affection is disrupted by drunk men who work at the site. They invade the communal area of the trailer before alcohol and loneliness cause them to attack Natalie. ​ Natalie is assaulted by them as Matt tries to protect her. He sacrifices his own life so that Natalie can run barefoot in the snow to get away from her assailants. For his trouble – and for simply loving a girl – he is beaten to death and thrown away like garbage. Casting Bernthal may have been a clever way of playing against the type of his typically darker characters. ​ When he first appears on-screen, there is a moment of dread as it seems for a moment that he could be the murderer. Instead, Matt brightens when he sees Natalie, exuding pure joy at seeing the person he loves. Matt is the only decent man at the oil site, laying down his life so he can save his girlfriend. This is even more tragic because his efforts are for naught. ​ Natalie runs six miles barefoot in the snow to escape, but her trauma and the cold lead to her freezing to death in the night. While the men did not technically kill her, they are 100 percent responsible for her death. Bernthal is an underrated part of this complex narrative that showed the heights the actor was capable of. In only one scene, Bernthal completely steals the show in his best and most devastating performance. ​

Original Source

Read the full article at Collider →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.