Published Nov 16, 2026, 11:01 AM EST Please prepare yourself for a Peanuts history lesson The best quote from A Charlie Brown Thanksgiving sums up the one significant thing about the special Please prepare yourself for a Peanuts history lesson Image: Charles Schulz There’s a reason why the animated TV special A Charlie Brown Thanksgiving isn’t mentioned nearly as often as A Charlie Brown Christmas and It's the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown, and that’s because, well, it stinks. Having enjoyed the process of choosing the best quote from the Peanuts Halloween special, I thought I’d do the same for the Thanksgiving special that I’m sure I watched as a kid, even if I didn’t really remember it. So I found the special online and started to watch it. Immediately, it felt like a chore to get through. The special is about Charlie Brown throwing a Thanksgiving dinner for a few of his pals, which he didn’t do by choice. On Thanksgiving morning, Charlie Brown gets a call from the pushy Peppermint Patty, who invites herself over for Thanksgiving dinner without letting Chuck get a word in over the phone. Charlie Brown was trying to explain that he won’t even be home for Thanksgiving because he’s going to his grandmother’s house, but he can’t manage to get the words out before Peppermint Patty abruptly hangs up. She then calls back a couple more times to say that Marcie and Franklin will also be coming. Again, Charlie Brown doesn’t get a chance to speak. He also doesn’t know how to cook, but he’s stuck making an impromptu dinner. Linus comes up with a solution: just to do an early dinner before he goes to his grandmother’s. Linus and Snoopy even help Charlie Brown make a feast of toast, popcorn and candy. Image: Charles Schulz As a premise, I guess that’s fine for Peanuts as it’s that low-stakes, slice-of-life kind of stuff that people love about Charles Schulz’s characters. The problem is it just comes off as a hollow attempt to capitalize on another holiday, with a script that has little of the life and humor of the more famous specials I mentioned. It's mostly just Charlie Brown stating his problems, Linus stating solutions, and people saying “Hello” to each other. Even worse than the script is the acting. Look, I realize how absurd it is to pick apart a 50-year-old Peanuts special for its acting, but if you actually sit down and watch the thing, it’s impossible to get over how slow and wooden it all feels. And yeah, I know that all of the Peanuts specials are kind of stilted, even the best ones. They are, after all, acted by children who are reading the scripts in front of them, and those real-kid voices add to the charm. The problem with this one is that it feels like they got a bunch of kids who are also not super strong readers, so the charm wears off in seconds. So with such a badly-acted special and uninspired script, I struggled to figure out what any “best” quote there could be because they’re pretty lousy. I tried to find something, anything, redeeming about the special besides the mildly amusing — and entirely silent — Snoopy animated gags. That’s when I landed upon Franklin and realized his mere presence in the special is worthy of note. Enter: Franklin Image: Charles Schulz Back then, Franklin was the only Black member of the Peanuts gang, and he was created for a very deliberate, forward-thinking reason back in 1968. On April 4, 1968, Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. was assassinated. Eleven days later, a white Los Angeles schoolteacher named Harriet Glickman wrote a letter to Schulz urging him to add a Black character to his immensely popular strip in an effort to promote racial equality at a time when the nation really needed people to take a stand. Schulz was unsure. In his reply to Glickman, he said that, while the thought had occurred to him, he feared “patronizing our Negro friends." Now, obviously, nearly 60 years later that quote doesn’t age super well, but it is reflective of the times. I’d also argue that Schulz’s actions in the months to come are far more significant than the dated language of a white guy born in 1922. Schulz continued his correspondence with Glickman and pretty quickly decided to add the character of Franklin to Peanuts, who first appeared in a comic strip on July 31, 1968. Set at the beach, Franklin finds Charlie Brown’s beach ball for him and gives it back to him. The two then share a moment talking about Charlie Brown’s crooked sandcastle. Over the next two days, they become friends and build a sandcastle together far better than the one Charlie Brown built on his own. Image: Charles Schulz The backlash against Schulz was swift and powerful. Many racist people objected to Franklin’s inclusion and said horrible things like he better not attend schools with the rest of the kids. United Feature Syndicate, which syndicated Peanuts, got so many letters that its president, Larry Rutman, asked Schulz to change the character. In reply, Schulz recalled saying, "Either you print it just the way I draw it or I quit. How's that?" Franklin stayed. Now, I’m not going to pretend Charles Schulz was some great civil rights leader, but it’s clear that, just in the matter of a few months in 1968, he went from a guy who wasn’t so sure if he should have a Black kid in his strip to a guy that threatened to quit over a Black character’s removal. He used his platform — which was huge at the time, with Peanuts in over 1,000 newspapers — to make a stand. The best quote from A Charlie Brown Thanksgiving Getting back to that terrible Thanksgiving special, the one thing I could find redeeming about it was that it was the first TV special to include Franklin, and it was released in 1973, just a few years after the initial Franklin controversy. He doesn’t do a whole lot in the special, but the fact that he’s there at all is significant. Ironically, in recent years, some people have called this special racist for this particular scene, which depicts all the white kids on one side of the Thanksgiving table in nicer chairs and Franklin alone on the other side with a crappy lawnchair, appearing to be segregated. Image: Charles Schulz On its own — and without any of the context of Franklin’s origins — I can understand why this image could be perceived as problematic, but I think it’s far more likely that it’s simply an oversight on the part of Schulz and Bill Melendez, the Mexican-American director of this and most of the other Peanuts TV specials. As for the chair, it falls apart during the dinner, in a callback to Snoopy’s earlier struggles with the chair, which I think it's fair to say that Schulz and Melendez were just trying to give Franklin — a character that Schulz hadn’t really developed all that much yet — something to do. There’s another part people criticize too. Charlie Brown gives Franklin a more complex “Black” handshake/high-five thing when he arrives. Yeah, it's dumb but I think it’s just a further case of them trying to give this kid a personality, which, admittedly, took Schulz a long time to do. Image: Charles Schulz I also think, given the context of Franklin’s creation and the way Schulz stood up for the character, it doesn’t make sense that he’d undermine his own principled stand from just a few years before. Given all that, I think the best quote in this special comes from Peppermint Patty (Franklin doesn’t get many lines). It comes after she invites herself, Marcie and Franklin to Charlie Brown’s house and Franklin says to her, “Do you think I should wear a tie?” Peppermint Patty’s response speaks volumes. She says: “No, you can come as you are, Franklin.” Now, perhaps I'm doing the same thing, in reverse, that those who accused this special of racism did by reading into something that may not be there. Regardless, Franklin is there. This special isn’t about all the Peanuts kids like the Christmas special was. In a special like that, Franklin could have been thrown in the background. But this special is different. There’s no Lucy or Schroeder or Pigpen coming to this dinner, and the characters included were deliberately chosen. It’s just Charlie Brown, Linus, Sally, Peppermint Patty, Marcie, and Franklin. It’s an intimate gathering between friends — equals — and that should be the takeaway.
53 Years Later, the Best ‘A Charlie Brown Thanksgiving’ Quote Is Classic ‘Peanuts’ Line
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Polygon →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.