For Donald Trump, his meeting with “friends” Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping was an “unbelievable” success. “On a scale of zero to 10, I think it was a 12,” he told NBC after the historic summit. European leaders, worried about the implications for Ukraine, took a different view. German Chancellor Friedrich Merz dismissed it as a “photo op”. The four point statement issued by Trump, Putin and Xi at the conclusion of the talks failed to mention the war in Ukraine, but Russia’s leader insisted it was discussed. How those discussions shape Ukraine’s future remains to be seen, but it is already clear the meeting will have consequences. Trump, Xi avoid specifics as Putin vows ‘painful’ response to Ukrainian attacks Both Xi and Trump largely avoided discussing the specifics of their three-way summit, although the US President was slightly more forthcoming. Asked by NBC about Volodymyr Zelenskyy’s call for the US and Russia not to make decisions about Ukraine behind its back, the President said he agreed with the Ukrainian leader. “He’s the head of that country, so I wouldn’t be doing that,” Trump said. He declined to offer more specific details on what was discussed, although his son-in-law and envoy, Jared Kushner, later said the President had “sent a very strong message to both of them [Putin and Xi] on the desire for peace and would like to engage both of them very aggressively to get there” when asked about the talks. Kushner’s comments struck a contrast with remarks delivered by Putin during an hour-long media conference after the three-way summit had concluded.While Russia’s President maintained he was open to “compromises” during negotiations to end the war, he largely cited a series of proposals stemming from a controversial summit with Trump in Alaska last year. That summit was criticised by Ukraine and European leaders as the resulting peace proposals almost entirely reflected maximalist demands from the Kremlin, including Ukrainian forces abandoning territory not controlled by Russia. Putin also repeated past claims Ukraine and its allies were “trying to put all the blame” for the war on Russia when it was his view Zelenskyy’s election and Ukrainian efforts to dispel Russian influence over the nation meant the invasion was necessary and justified. Russia’s leader also declared he would “not come to an agreement” on a ceasefire in the wake of Ukraine’s destruction of part of the Kerch Bridge, which links Russia with the occupied Crimean peninsula. The bridge, which Ukraine has repeatedly attacked, is symbolically important to Putin and he vowed the latest strikes would be met with a “considerably more painful” response. European leaders dismissive, but wary On the same day Trump, Xi and Putin sat down to discuss international affairs, European leaders held a separate meeting aimed at presenting a united front on Ukraine. The conference in Berlin, deliberately scheduled to coincide with Trump’s three-way summit, saw multiple leaders push back on Putin’s claims and hints the US could adopt a more pro-Kremlin stance in negotiations. “Putin is not and never will be our friend,” Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk told media after the meeting, in a direct reference to Trump’s description of the Russian President. At the same time Trump, Xi and Putin sat down to discuss international affairs, European leaders held a separate meeting aimed at presenting a united front on Ukraine (Photo: Hannah McKay/Pool/Getty Images) Germany’s Chancellor was less blunt, but equally quick to downplay the importance of the three-way summit – he called it a “photo op”. “Negotiations involving Ukraine and Europe can only succeed if conducted together. A Yalta-style format will not bring peace,” Merz added, reflecting growing concerns in Europe over the direction of future negotiations to end the war. While Kushner said Trump called in to update Zelenskyy and European leaders after his meeting with Putin and Xi, a call Prime Minister Andy Burnham said included an admission the war was “lose-lose for everybody,” The Times reported the US President had questioned European spending on Ukraine’s defence. “He was telling the Europeans: ‘Enough already, you’re spending so much money on the war and you need to be spending it on your own countries’,” an unnamed source told the outlet. Wariness over Trump’s position is likely to persist, even though Putin on Thursday appeared to have conceded ground to joint European and US requests for Ukraine’s allies to have a seat at the negotiating table. Russia’s leader told media the Kremlin had “suggested through diplomatic channels that the Europeans come to Moscow to define their position”. Putin declined to reveal which leaders had been invited, although European officials last week said a coalition of France, Germany, Italy, Poland, and the UK, plus the European Union and Nato, would represent the continent during future negotiations. Summit delivers Putin symbolic win, even if real-world impact limited Despite the largely dismissive response from European leaders, experts have highlighted the important symbolic impact the trilateral summit will have for Putin. Richard Stengel, a former US under secretary of state, said the meeting was a “dream” for Russia’s President. “The reason no American president has ever had a trilateral meeting with Russia and China is because no American president has ever been willing to put our two principal adversaries on equal footing with the United States,” he wrote in a social media post. “Russia is a second-tier power with nuclear weapons. This trilat [trilateral meeting] is Putin’s dream. It restores him to the world order after his invasion of Ukraine. Shameful.” Aaron Glasserman, from Columbia University’s Weatherhead East Asian Institute, concurred, telling Al Jazeera Putin “got to re-legitimise Russia’s place in the international order” and “gained legitimacy” for his invasion of Ukraine. Ukrainian officials were also quick to highlight Putin’s effort to project strength. “Putin posed as a global leader in Shenzhen. In reality, he is a global criminal and terrorist. And he should be treated as such,” the nation’s Foreign Minister, Andrii Sybiha, said in a social media post. “Time for him to wake up, get real, and end the war he can never win.”
12 out of 10 or ‘photo op’: Did Trump, Xi, Putin summit shift dial on Ukraine?
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Inews →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.