10th Circuit skeptical of expanding Oklahoma juvenile parole rights

10th Circuit skeptical of expanding Oklahoma juvenile parole rights

A man convicted in a triple murder committed when he was 15 says Oklahoma unconstitutionally fails to take age during the crime into consideration during parole reviews.(CN) — An attorney for Dwain Edward Thomas told a 10th Circuit panel Monday that the Eighth Amendment requires states to treat parole review for juvenile homicide offenders differently from adults.“Mr. Thomas was only 15 when he committed his crimes, a child both physically and mentally,” Caroline Robinson of Kirkland & Ellis said. “The Oklahoma parole system fails this constitutional mandate.”The three-judge panel must decide if Oklahoma must build youth consideration into every stage of parole review for juvenile homicide offenders, or whether the Eighth Amendment only requires discretion at sentencing. The amendment protects from excessive bail and fines, and cruel and unusual punishments.Robinson argued that Oklahoma never ensures decision makers know if they are dealing with a juvenile or that they weigh subsequent maturity and rehabilitation throughout the parole process.U.S. Circuit Judge Jerome A. Holmes, a George W. Bush appointee, asked what prevented the Oklahoma parole board from considering age.Robinson said the investigative reports do not reliably convey it, with only one report explicitly stating Thomas’ age at the time of the offense. She said board members reviewing 250 to 500 cases a month cannot be expected to calculate ages at the time of offense in every case.“The parole board members need to be given the means and the information in order to be able to apply the meaningful opportunity,” she said, adding that in some earlier reports age had been treated as an aggravating factor.U.S. Circuit Judge Carolyn B. McHugh observed that the reports contain birth dates and case file years, and that in 2016 and 2019, investigators recommended parole in part because of Thomas’ youth.Robinson said that constitutional protection must apply every time, not only when someone happens to notice and rely on it.“What we are asking you to tell Oklahoma is that, in consideration of juvenile offenders, only juveniles are entitled to this Eighth Amendment protection and meaningful consideration must be afforded,” she said.McHugh noted that U.S. Supreme Court precedent in Miller v. Alabama addressed mandatory life without parole sentences for juvenile homicide offenders and Graham v. Florida’s “meaningful opportunity” standard applied to non-homicide cases.The Barack Obama appointee also asked whether Robinson was seeking a rule the court has not adopted for someone sentenced to life with parole.Robinson said the principles already support relief.“Graham held that a state must give juvenile offenders a meaningful opportunity to obtain release based on demonstrated maturity and rehabilitation,” she said, adding that nothing in the cases makes the protections crime-specific.William Patrick Flanagan, representing Oklahoma officials, argued that the Supreme Court has required only a discretionary sentencing process that considers youth before imposing life without parole.“When Thomas was a juvenile offender, he was afforded precisely that process and he was awarded a life sentence with the possibility of parole,” Flanagan said, emphasizing that Thomas’ claim demands a mandatory, specific criterion at every stage of parole review — an extension no appeals circuit has accepted.“Existing Supreme Court precedent does not require that the pardon and parole board and the entire apparatus that Oklahoma provides have a specific criterion that they are mandated to consider juvenile status at the time of the crime,” Flanagan argued.Holmes asked whether Thomas was also arguing that Oklahoma’s system is a “full-on sham” that effectively converts life with parole into life without parole. Flanagan said no; the claim is limited to the absence of a required youth consideration.McHugh asked whether a purely sham process would violate the Eighth Amendment. Flanagan agreed it would raise concerns, but said that is not the argument presented.On rebuttal, Robinson clarified that the claim is that the system fails to provide a meaningful opportunity for juvenile offenders because it is not structured to consider juvenile status throughout.“Not just mandated, but even if they wanted to, they don’t have the tools or information necessary to be able to,” she said, distinguishing her case from a claim that no one can ever obtain parole.The panel did not make any decision Monday and took the case under submission.Subscribe to our free newslettersOur weekly newsletter Closing Arguments offers the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world, while the monthly Under the Lights dishes the legal dirt from Hollywood, sports, Big Tech and the arts.Additional Reads

Original Source

Read the full article at Courthousenews →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.